This bibliography is intended to include the Dante translations published in this country in 1983 and all Dante studies and reviews published in 1983 that are in any sense American. The latter criterion is construed to include foreign reviews of American publications pertaining to Dante. The listing of reviews in general is selective, particularly in the case of studies bearing only peripherally on Dante.
As a rule, items cited from Dissertation Abstracts International are registered without further abstracting, since the titles tend to be self-explanatory. Items not recorded in the bibliographies for previous years are entered as addenda to the present list.
Generally, the citation of an individual study from a collected volume representing several authors is given in brief, while the main entry of the volume is listed with full bibliographical data in its alphabetical order. Issues of this journal under the former title of Annual Report of the Dante Society continue to be cited in the short form of Report, with volume number.
In this instance, I wish to express my profound appreciation to
Teodolinda Barolini, Joan M. Ferrante, Christopher Kleinhenz,
and Richard H. Lansing for their collegial spirit of cooperation
and their substantial assistance in the abstracting of a number
of items for this bibliography.
[Paradiso, excerpts] "Paradiso: Lines from a New Translation." Translated by Stefan Brecht. In Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer): [Special Issue] "Dante in the Modern World," edited by Kathleen Verduin, pp. 79-85. [1983]
Presents some selected short passages from Paradiso II,
III, V, VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, and XII, interspersed with a very
free prose translation.
[Four Latin letters: Epistolae V-VIII.] In Babylon on the Rhone: A Translation of the Letters by Dante, Petrarch, and Catherine of Siena on the Avignon Papacy, translated by Robert Cogan (Studia Humanitatis; Madrid: José Porrúa Turanzas). [1983]
Provides an English translation only, with notes, of Epistolae
V-VIII, along with a general introduction discussing the state
of Italy and Dante's ideas about the kind of government needed
for the Empire, as compared with the ideas of Petrarch and Saint
Catherine on the subject.
Abrash, Merritt. "Dante's Hell as an Ideal Mechanical Environment." In Clockwork Worlds: Mechanized Environments in SF, edited by Richard D. Erlich, Thomas P. Dunn, and Arthur O. Lewis (Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press), pp. 21-25. (Contributions to the Study of Science Fiction and Fantasy, 7.) [1983]
Contends that Dante genially intuited an astonishingly modern
conception of an ideally mechanistic environment for the damned,
a beehive contrived between two analogues of machines, the figures
of Minos and Satan, with the whole standardized and repetitive
infernal operation functioning automatically and without recourse.
Ammons, Elizabeth. "Infanticide and Other Ways of Mothering in Anne Redmon's Music and Silence." In Texas Studies in Literature and Language, XXV, No. 2 (Summer), 343-363. [1983]
Analyzes suggestive themes in this novel about a woman artist,
which "borrows both cast and geography" from Dante's
Comedy for one of its image systems together with that
of childbearing.
Anderson, David. "Mandelbaum and the Modernist Dante." In Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer), 87-96. [Special Dante issue, q.v.] [1983]
Review-article focusing on the translations of the Divine Comedy
by C.H. Sisson (see Dante Studies, C, 133-134 and 156)
and of the Inferno and Purgatorio by Allen Mandelbaum
(see Dante Studies, XCIX, 173-174, and CI, 193-194, 215
and 222), concluding in favor of the latter: "Mandelbaum's
Dante reflects the best principles of modern verse translation."
Anderson, David. editor. Pound's Cavalcanti: An Edition
... See Pound, Ezra, Pound's Cavalcanti....
Arrowsmith, William. "Ruskin's Fireflies." In Pequod, XV, 83-107. [1983]
First installment of a study on John Ruskin's concept of the "Imagination
Penetrative," representing the cumulus of layer upon layer
of literary and personal texts and impressions that are the resources
on which the poet draws for imagery and expressive means generally.
The author cites, among others, the example of Dante whose influence
pervades Ruskin's work and for whom, along with C.W. Norton, he
had a consuming passion.
Baglivi, Giuseppe. "Dall'eterno al tempo: studio dantesco." In Dissertation Abstracts International, XLIII, No. 9 (March), 2989A. [1983]
Doctoral dissertation, Indiana University, 1982. 199 p. [Italian
text.] (Reexamines the Veltro passage, Inf. I, 103-105,
and re-interpreting the Commedia as a whole from this perspective,
identifies the Veltro as Dante himself.)
Barricelli, Jean-Pierre (Joint author). "Dante and
Rulfo: Beyond Time through Eternity." See Rodríguez-Alcalá,
Hugo....
Benoit, Raymond. "Dante's Inferno, Canto V, 4-15."In Explicator, XLI, No. 3 (Spring), 2. [1983]
Sees in the soul confessing all before Minos a re-enactment of
the Sacrament of Penance, but in dramatic contrast to what might
have been, with possible salvation of the sinner.
Bergin, Thomas G. "Dante's Provencal Gallery"
(1965). Reprinted in Dante in America . . . (q.v.), pp.
325-344. [1983]
Bergin, Thomas G. "The Presence of Dante." In Sewanee Review, XX, No. 2 (Spring), 261-269. [1983]
Omnibus review of recent translations of Dante and works on Dante:
The Divine Comedy, trans. by C.H. Sisson; the Purgatorio,
trans. by Allen Mandelbaum; Purgatorio, trans. by Mark
Musa; Rime, trans. by Patrick S. Diehl; George Holmes,
Dante; Approaches to Teaching Dante's "Divine Comedy,"
edited by Carole Slade; Mary T. Reynolds, Joyce and Dante;
William Anderson, Dante the Maker; and Jerome Mazzaro,
The Figure of Dante: An Essay on the "Vita Nuova,"
all separately listed in full below, under Reviews.
Bernardo, Aldo S. (Joint editor). See Dante, Petrarch,
Boccaccio: Studies in the Italian Trecento in Honor of Charles
S. Singleton ....
Bigongiari, Dino. "The Art of the Canzone" (1950).
Reprinted in Dante in America ... (q.v.), pp. 228-243.
[1983]
Bommarito, Domenico. "Il mito di Ulisse e la sua allegorizzazione in Boezio e Dante. Ulisse: il tema dell"homo insipiens."' In Forum Italicum, XVII, No. 1 (Spring), 64-81. [1983]
Moving from Boethius' treatment of Ulysses as a figure of the
sapiens who is master of his passions in the Consolatio
Philosophiae, the author argues that Dante reprises the same
concepts in the Comedy: his Ulysses' sin is insipientia
(absence of sapientia) and with him Dante seeks to condemn
a human prototype who had been idolized in the past and was resurfacing
in his own times.
Caserta, Ernesto G. "Gli studi danteschi di Rocco Montano." In Dante Studies, CI, 145-166. [1983]
Offers an assessment and appreciation of Montano's Dantean studies,
finding them often polemical, but invariably essential, innovative,
seminal. Not adequately recognized, for example, is Montano's
elaboration of the now widely accepted crucial distinction between
Dante-Poet and Dante-Protagonist for a proper reading of the Commedia.
The author also highlights Montano's countering of a tendency
to read Dante's poem according to a modern sensibility, by placing
Dante in his own historico-cultural context.
Cassell, Anthony K. "Pier della Vigna's Metamorphosis: Iconography and History." In Dante, Petrarch, Boccaccio: Studies in the Italian Trecento ... (q.v.), pp. 31-76. [1983]
Marshals rich historical, Biblical, exegetical, and iconographical
evidence to coordinate with the poet's diction, imagery, and allusions
in Inferno XIII, in order to demonstrate that Pier della
Vigna, far from the tragically innocent victim of Romantic interpretation,
was indeed a criminal, guilty of "corruption in office, perversion
of justice, and self-enrichment at the expense of the innocent
and the state." Though his protesting words may play upon
the pity of the ignorant Dante-wayfarer, Pier is aptly condemned
by the all-knowing Dante-poet to his proper place in the penal
system of Hell, incorporating all the manifold elements that identify
Pier for what he really was and underscoring a parallel between
him and the canonical epitome of avarice and suicide, Judas Iscariot.
Comes with fourteen half-tone illustrations.
Cavalcanti, Guido. The Sonnets and Ballate of Guido Cavalcanti. With translation and introduction by Ezra Pound. Westport, Connecticut: Hyperion Press. xxiv, 119 p. 22 cm. [1983]
Photographic reprint of the 1912 edition (Boston: Small, Maynard);
Italian and English version on facing pages. Includes three sonnets
to Dante, Vedesti al mio parere ogni valore, Io vengo il giorno
infinite volte, and Dante, un sospiro messager del core.
In his introduction (pp. xi-xxiv) Pound draws suggestive poetic
links between Dante and Guido.
Cavalcanti, Guido. See Pound, Ezra, Pound's Cavalcanti....
Chiampi, James T. "Dante's Pilgrim and Reader in the 'Region of Want."' In Stanford Italian Review, III, No. 2 (Fall), 163-182. [1983]
In this dense hermeneutic meditation, the author views Dante's
pilgrim, the poem itself, and the reader as undergoing the same
spiritual development (or exercitatio animi), involving
a journey along the way of truth from the visibilia, or
signs, through the invisibilia, to res, of God Himself.
The process is marked by the inadequate guidance of Virgil, arrested
at the stage of the child, and the effectual guidance of Beatrice
graduated to the progressive stages with which the pilgrim matures
in wisdom. The author dwells on the many metaphorical and imagistic
terms of maturation and especially of hunger and food/nutrition,
which, like the poem as a whole, serve the poet's procedure, not
for the primary value of literary effect or artistic beauty, but
for effectively fulfilling his mission of leading mankind, bound
to the ways of this world, to the way of Truth. Indeed "the
entire Paradiso is actually an immense banquet of deifying
knowledge wherein the pilgrim finds the truth of his being by
feeding upon the truth...." Even the poet's addresses to
the reader, in turn, echo the Beatricean sternness that is guiding
his own spiritual transformation along the way of the poem, suggesting
the proportion, Dante:reader::Beatrice:Dante. Dante, "like
Augustine eating of God has been changed into Him [and] thus may
call himself a lamb militant."
Chiarenza, Marguerite Mills. "Boethian Themes in Dante's Reading of Virgil." In Stanford Italian Review, III, No. 1 (Spring), 25-35. [1983]
Argues that we can better understand the role of the Aeneid
in the Comedy in the light of Boethius' Consolatio Philosophiae,
especially Book IV. Virgil's stoic pessimism did not go unnoticed
by Dante; Anchises cannot give Aeneas the consolation Cacciaguida
gives Dante. Cacciaguida's prophecy is the supplanting and resolution
not just of previous prophecies, but of Virgil's whole human perspective.
The pilgrim's exile, as he fears it, is Fate in the Boethian sense,
while Cacciaguida's interpretation of that exile is a reflection
of the Boethian view of Providence. The central example of Fate
in the Comedy is the Aeneid, which is reread providentially:
thus, Dante chose to save Ripheus because of Virgil's fatalistic
"dis aliter visum" (Aen. II, 428). The corrections
of the Aeneid in the Comedy are not so much Christian
readings superimposed on a pagan text as Providence's readings
superimposed on Fate.
Chiarenza, Marguerite Mills. "Time and Eternity in the Myths of Paradiso XVII." In Dante, Petrarch, Boccaccio: Studies in the Italian Trecento . . . (q.v.), pp. 133-150. [1983]
Shows how the mythical allusions and the imagery in Cacciaguida's
prophecy confirm the eventual happy outcome of Dante-pilgrim from
fall into exile in the contingency of this temporal life to ultimate
triumph, on the pattern, not of the myth of Phaeton, but that
of Hippolytus, who was eventually resurrected as Virbius. (See
also the author's article on "Hippolytus' Exile ..."
in Dante Studies, LXXXIV, 65-68.)
Cioffari, Vincenzo. "Inferno XIII from Laurentian Pluteo 40.2 and Its Sources." In Dante Studies, CI, 1-25. [1983]
As a specimen of his work in progress for providing source materials
from unedited manuscripts of the earliest commentaries, the author
presents here from Laurentian Pluteo 40.2 the key canto, Inferno,
XIII, for determining chronological sequence of the commentaries.
In parallel columns are reproduced the Plut. 40.2 text on the
left and on the right the sources of the commentaries-- primarily
from the Commentum of Benvenuto da Imola and the Expositiones
of Guido da Pisa.
Cioffari, Vincenzo. "Latin Commentary on Paradiso XI from Egerton 943." In Forum Italicum, XVII, No. 1 (Spring), 53-63. [1983]
Discusses the Egerton 943 in light of other fragmentary manuscripts,
all pointing to the existence of an integral Latin commentary
which he designates the Anonimo latino, important for being
one of the earliest, and presents a transcription of the part
dealing with Paradiso XI, with which it abruptly ends,
probably because the commentator was a Dominican and the Florentine
chapter had issued an order in 1335 against reading the Commedia.
Crookes, David Z. "Dante's Paradiso, Canto XXI." In Explicator, XLI, No. 3 (Spring), 3-5. [1983]
Suggests that in the context of allusions to wheels and rotation
in this canto the specific verses 58-60 may be a metaphor-pun
based on two common medieval string instruments, the sinfonia
(hurdy-gurdy, activated by a wheel, or rota) and the rota
(crowd, or crwth).
Culbertson, Diana. "Dante, the Yahwist, and the Sins of Sodom." In Italian Culture, IV, 11-23. [1983]
Male sexual acts are metaphorical in the Yahwist (Genesis 19:
Sodom and Gomorrah) and in Dante, who borrows much of his imagery
for Inferno XV and XVI from Genesis. The Yahwist writer
is not concerned with homosexuality, but with acceptance of the
true God and charity for strangers. The people of Sodom used rape
to express contempt and hatred for the "neighbor"; rape
signified contempt for captured soldiers and, in Jewish culture,
also religious persecution. In Inferno XV as well, sodomy
is a metaphor for indifference to the life of grace, for the choice
of humanistic immortality as a substitute for eternal life with
God. Moreover, such a sin is one that Dante, who was preoccupied
by both the humanistic and the spiritual implications of immortality
and who knew that the Comedy would make him literally immortal,
had reason to fear: he knew what Brunetto did not know, that literary
immortality is not salvific.
Dante in America: The First Two Centuries. Edited by A. Bartlett Giamatti. Binghamton, New York: Medieval and Renaissance Texts and Studies. xii, 412 p. illus. 24 cm. [1983]
Conveniently gathers together, reprinted from various sources,
a representative selection of 23 pieces (1819-1981) designed to
portray the development of Dante criticism in the United States
during the first two centuries of the nation's existence. The
authors, in chronological order of their selected essay, are:
Gray, Da Ponte, Longfellow (2), Norton, Lowell, Harris, Santayana,
Rand, Wilkins, Grandgent, Pound, Silverstein, Eliot, Bigongiari,
Singleton, Tate, Fergusson, Mazzeo, Bergin, Freccero, Hollander,
Fitzgerald. The essays are separately registered by author in
this bibliography. There is an editorial preface by A.B. Giamatti.
The facts of original publication of the essays are duly indicated
in a list of"Bibliographical Sources" (pp. 411-412).
"Dante in the Modern World," edited by Kathleen Verduin.
See Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer): special
Dante issue (q.v.).
Dante, Petrarch, Boccaccio: Studies in the Italian Trecento in Honor of Charles S. Singleton. Edited by Aldo S. Bernardo and Anthony L. Pellegrini. Binghamton, New York: Medieval and Renaissance Texts and Studies. xxviii, 366 p. front., illus. 24.5 cm. [1983]
Contains eight essays of Dantean interest by A.K. Cassell, M.M.
Chiarenza, J.M. Ferrante, J. Freccero, R. Hollander, R.E. Kaske,
E. Raimondi, and A. Vallone, which are separately listed in this
bibliography. The volume comes with a Preface, Tabula Gratulatoria,
Introduction (paying tribute to Singleton as a leading Dantista
of our time), and The Publications of Charles S. Singleton.
Da Ponte, Lorenzo. "Critique of Certain Passages in
Dante" (1825). Reprinted in Dante in America . . . (q.v.),
pp. 27-34. [1983]
De Bonfils Templer, Margherita. "La donna gentile del Convivio e il boeziano mito d'Orfeo." In Dante Studies, CI, 123-144. [1983]
Relates the donna gentile episode in the Vita nuova
to Boethius' treatment of the Orpheus myth in the De Consolatione
Philosophiae (with its central figure of Philosophia), involving
a turning back with difficulty and inconsolably toward lost sensual
bonds. The Convivio (with its theme of intellectual love),
in turn, with particular reference to II, i, is seen as a transitional
stage in the philosophical-spiritual development of Dante's love
from the literal Beatrice of the Vita nuova, notwithstanding
the final sonnet with its vision of a spiritual love not yet attained,
to the achievement of the latter in the Commedia. Dante's
conflating of the allegorized donna gentile in the Convivio
with the donna gentile of the Vita nuova serves
as a transition to the ultimate synthesis of the polysemous figure
of Beatrice in the Commedia.
Di Scipio, Giuseppe C. "The Hebrew Women in Dante's Symbolic Rose." In Dante Studies, CI, 111-121. [1983]
Cites Biblical and exegetical evidence to account for Dante's
particular variant (from the Biblical) order of Hebrew women (Mary,
Eve, Rachel, Sara, Rebecca, Judith, Ruth) in their alignment to
demarcate the two sections representing the Old and New Testaments
in the White Rose described in Paradiso XXXII. Generally
speaking, moreover, each of the seven women noted for their excellence
is in some way a figura ecclesiae, their number in turn
being associated, among other things, with the seven churches
of Apocalypse.
Doolittle, Nancy Jean. "Landscape and Spatial Perspective in Dante, Ariosto, and Milton." In Dissertation Abstracts International, XLIII, No. 12 (June), 3901A. [1983]
Doctoral dissertation, State University of New York at Binghamton,
1983. 355 p. (Examines cosmological patterns and motifs in the
Divine Comedy, Orlando furioso, and Paradise Lost
and their unifying effect, noting that in Dante's poem the rivers
are emblems of the concept of God as Point and Circumference.)
Elata-Aster, Gerda. "Gathering the Leaves and Squaring the Circle: Recording, Reading and Writing in Dante's Vita Nuova and Divina Commedia." In Italian Quarterly, XXIV, No. 92 (Spring), 5-26. [1983]
The Vita Nuova presents an unstable structure in which
the reader moves from minor image to mirror image vainly searching
for meaning, but finding only names. Naming is the movement of
circularity. In the Comedy, instead of displacing meaning
from name to name in an auto-erotic circuit, Dante's discourse
is able to leave the circle through the voice of the Other, instructing
him in the writing of the book, so that the poet "becomes
the recording, the reading, and the writing
in one."
Eliot, T.S. "A Talk on Dante" (1950). Reprinted
in Dante in America ... (q.v.), pp.219-227. [1983]
Elliott, Angela. "Pound's Lucifer: A Study in the Imagery of Flight and Light." In Paideuma, XII, Nos. 2-3 (Fall-Winter), 237-266. [1983]
Starting with "When Lucifer fell in N. Carolina" (Pisan
Cantos 74.425), the author shows that Pound's use of flight
imagery is akin to Dante's. The episode of the Wright brothers
"fulfills both the original glory and the shocking fall of
the original Lucifer"; Ulysses-like and Lucifer-like, aircraft
are both a triumph of the intellect and engines of destruction.
The machine-like nature of Dante's Lucifer is invoked by Pound
in his linking of machines, airplanes, usury, and war: "To
hint at the place of Lucifer's fall in the making of our present
age is what Pound appears to attempt in The Cantos."
Fergusson, Francis. "The Fine Veil of Poetry,"
"[Purg.] Canto IX: The Prophetic First Night,"
and "On the Dramatic Coherence of the Canto" (1953).
Reprinted in Dante in America . . . (q.v.), pp.274-292.
[1983]
Ferrante, Joan M. "Words and Images in the Paradiso: Reflections of the Divine." In Dante, Petrarch, Boccaccio: Studies in the Italian Trecento . . . (q.v.), pp. 115-132. [1983]
Examines how Dante experiments with linguistic techniques and
imagery to cope with the difficulty of communicating that which
is beyond expressibility in human language as such. Through effective
use of such devices as neologism, repetition, homonym, blending
of Lating and Italian, fusing of two words to form a third, the
poet reflects harmony achieved through diversity, reconciliation
of opposites and of paradoxes, even the mystic union of separate
beings--all things associated with the Divine, of which the whole
cantica of the Paradiso itself is a visual and linguistic
expression.
Fitzgerald, Robert. "Mirroring the Commedia:
An Appreciation of Laurence Binyon's Version" (I981). Reprinted
in Dante in America . . . (q.v.), pp. 390-410. [1983]
Fowlie, Wallace. "Faith and Narrative in Dante." In Notre Dame English Journal, XV, No. 2 (Spring), 67-76. [1983]
Meditates upon the Comedy as the clearest narrative record
of faith after the Bible, in which Dante utilizes everything to
illuminate the whole cosmos, and also creates an extraordinary
cast of characters, "the first examples in European literature
of what will be called later 'personality' or the sometimes conflicting
traits of an individual." According to the author, moreover,
the Inferno, specifically, is "the leading model for
our modern novel of the self," which he illustrates, for
example, with Proust and Joyce and more particularly with the
contemporary Flannery O'Connor's Wise Blood and William
Beckett's drama Waiting for Godot. All these writers, especially
Dante, possessed the ability to create a second world--of the
imagination.
Freccero, John. "Manfred's Wounds and the Poetics of the Purgatorio." In Centre and Labyrinth: Essays in Honour of Northrop Frye, edited by Eleanor Cook, Chaviva Hosek, Jay Macpherson, Patricia Parker, and Julian Patrick (Toronto: University of Toronto Press), pp. 69-82. [1983]
Unlike Odysseus' scar, which is merely there, Manfred's wounds
demand an interpretation. "Manfred's wounds are like the
marks of history . . . like writing itself they deface in the
name of significance." This analogy between the aerial bodies
of the souls and the writing that represents them leads to a discussion
of Statius' discourse on conception and reproduction in Purgatorio
XXV, which in turn provides an analogy between the act of writing
and the act of procreation and may be used to gloss Purgatorio
XXIV. The analogy between Manfred's wounds and poetic text is
further underscored by the P's on the pilgrim's brow, marks that
are both wounds and letters. If you can read Manfred's face--unlike
the pastor of Cosenza--you can read the poem.
Freccero, John. "Paradiso X: The Dance of the
Stars" (1968). Reprinted in Dante in America ... (q.v.),
pp. 345-371. [1983]
Freccero, John. "The Significance of terza rima." In Dante, Petrarch, Boccaccio: Studies in the Italian Trecento ... (q.v.), pp. 3-17. [1983]
Interprets the meaning of terza rima in terms of a temporal
pattern of past, present, and future, with which the formal structure
and the thematics of the whole poem coordinate homologically:
"both the verse pattern and the theme proceed by a forward
motion which is at the same time recapitulary." Following
the same pattern in the three conceptual orders of the formal,
thematical, and logical, the autobiographical narrative too is
seen "as forward motion that moves towards its own beginning,
or as a form of advance and recovery, leading toward a final recapitulation."
And the same pattern is found especially to obtain theologically
and biblically (i.e., historically). By way of recapitulation,
the author concludes with a passage from Augustine's Confessions
on the nature of time, which "conforms exactly to the movement
of terza rima." Comes with six diagrams illustrating
the various patterns elaborated in the text.
Friedman, John Block. "Medieval Cartography and Inferno XXXIV: Lucifer's Three Faces Reconsidered." In Traditio, XXXIX, 447-456. [1983]
Cites iconographical evidence primarily from maps to suggest that
Dante reflects in his figuration of Satan (Inf. XXXIV)
a number of cartographic features with which the poet must have
been familiar. For example, the three heads of Dante's Satan in
their respective three colors are seen to represent the three
known continents, Europe, Asia, and Africa, and the crucified
Christ figured in many mappamundi, suggesting the Crucifixion
as the central event of the world, is seen as part of the parodic
situation of Satan in Cocytus. Comes with twelve glossy illustrations.
Giamatti, A. Bartlett, editor. Dante in America . .
. (q.v.).
Grandgent, Charles H. "The Pentateuch and the Divine
Comedy" (1929-30). Reprinted in Dante in America .
. . (q.v.), pp. 160-174. [1983]
Gray, John Chipman. "[Review of La Divina Commedia]"
(1819). (1. La Divina Commedia di Dante Alighieri, Firenze,
1813; 2. The Vision, or Hell Purgatory and Paradise of Dante
Alighieri, translated by the Rev. H.F. Cary, A.M., in three
volumes, 1814.) Reprinted in Dante in America . . . (q.v.),
pp. 3-26. [1983]
Harris, W.T. "The Spiritual Sense of Dante's Divina
Commedia" (1887). Reprinted in Dante in America .
. . (q.v.), pp. 87-115. [1983]
Hay, Eloise. "T.S. Eliot's Virgil: Dante." in Journal of English and Germanic Philology, LXXXII, No. 1 (Jan.), 50-65. [1983]
Dante, and specifically Dante's use of Virgil, is the key to one
of Eliot's main rhetorical devices: his metaphors of meditation.
For Eliot, Dante's Virgil is the middle term between dead past
and unborn future; while his early poetry shows resistance to
Dante by borrowing in an ironical context, in "Ash Wednesday"
Eliot encounters a mediatrix of his own, and in "Four Quartets"
he is able to dismiss Dante, as Dante dismisses Virgil.
Heaney, Seamus. "From Station Island." In Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer), 15-17. [Special Dante issue, q.v.] [1983]
Offers an excerpt of 55 lines, in tercet form, from section XIV
of a longer poem, inspired by Dante's Comedy, on Station
Island, otherwise known as St. Patrick's Purgatory.
Heilbronn, Denise. "Master Adam and the Fat-Bellied Lute (Inf. XXX)." In Dante Studies, CI, 51-65. [1983]
Brings to bear Biblical and symbolical associations upon the lute
(or cithara) as central image of Inferno XXX, and sees
Master Adam cast by Dante in the suggestively cruciform aspect
of a lute as figuring a "counterfeit" cross, an ironic
non-salvific, negative crucifixion.
Hiscoe, David W. 'Dante's Poetry, Daedalus' Monster, and Arnaut Daniel's Name." In Italica, LX, No. 3 (Autumn), 246-255. [1983]
Argues that the historical Arnaut Daniel encountered in Purgatorio
XXVI is a figure for the "re-formed" poet, by way of
the visual pun "Ieu sui-Iesu," and, more importantly,
by way of the conspicuous absence of the troubadour's surname.
The author further elaborates on allusions to the Book of Daniel
in these cantos and on the importance of the prophet Daniel as
a model for Dante.
Hollander, Robert. "'Ad ira parea mosso': God's Voice in the Garden (Inf. XXIV, 69)." In Dante Studies, CI, 27-49. [1983]
Favors the old reading ira (rather than ire) in
verse 69 of Inferno XXIV, 64-78, because of the many parodic
parallels between the episode (together with xxv) and the Edenic
scene of original sin. The riddle of the wrathful voice heard
by Dante in XXIV, in short, turns out to be that of Cacus (XXV)
echoing that of the Lord in Genesis.
Hollander, Robert. "A Checklist of Commentators on the Commedia (1322-1982)." In Dante Studies, CI, 181-192. [1983]
Lists for convenient reference 130 of the more significant commentaries
on the Commedia, from the earliest to the most recent,
chronologically with name of commentator, date, and bibliographical
information.
Hollander, Robert. "Purgatorio XIX: Dante's Siren/Harpy." In Dante, Petrarch, Boccaccio: Studies in the Italian Trecento ... (q.v.), pp. 78-88. [1983]
Cites pertinent texts from Ovid, Boethius, Isidore of Seville,
and Virgil, to bear on the strega/siren figure in Dante's
second dream in Purgatory (XIX, 7-36), but finds the most convincing
source in Virgil's description of harpies in Aeneid III,
216-218. This finding coordinates with the author's hypothesis
that the donna santa e onesta of this dream is Beatrice
and with the harpies episode of Inferno XIII, 10-15, and
also with the scene of Beatrice's harsh judgment of Dante's straying
(Purg. XXXI, 134).
Hollander, Robert. "Tragedy in Dante's Comedy." In Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2 (Spring), 240-260. [1983]
Asks what Dante meant when he called his poem a "comedy"
and Virgil's Aeneid a "tragedy." The plot of
the Comedy is comic and therefore must employ low style,
but as a sacred poem, it must treat sublimely of supernal truth.
As Dante notes in his epistle to Can Grande, Horace allows mixed
style, and Dante's poem is mixed in its vocabulary, though never
in its plot. The Aeneid, on the other hand, is tragic for
Dante in various ways: Dido's love, Turnus not being spared in
the end, Virgil's lack of faith in Christ to come. Yet without
Virgil's tragedy, there would have been no Comedy.
Hollander, Robert. Il Virgilio dantesco: tragedia nella "Commedia." Firenze: Leo S. Olschki. 155 p. 24 cm. (Biblioteca di "Lettere italiane." Studi e testi, XXVIII.) [1983]
In these three essays, the author elaborates his position that,
although Dante evinces his awareness of medieval allegorizings
of the Aeneid, he abandons this interest in an allegorized
Aeneid in the Divina Commedia and treats Virgil
simply historically, with one motive being to call to task the
credibility of Virgil's teaching/guidance. Contents: Introduzione;
Nota bibliografica; I. Inferno I, 63: "chi per lungo
silenzio parea fioco" e la tradizione esegetica; II. Travisamenti
danteschi dell'Eneide; III. Tragedia nella Commedia.
(The essays were translated by Anna Maria Castellini, the notes
by Margherita Frankel.) It is duly noted by the author that parts
of the first two essays echo previous studies (see Dante Studies,
LXXXVII, 161-162, and LXXXVIII, 185-186; XCIX, 183-184), while
the third essay represents an expansion of a previous version
that appeared as "Tragedy in Dante's Comedy"
in Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2 (Summer 1983), 240-260 (see
previous item).
Hollander, Robert. "Vita Nuova: Dante's Perceptions
of Beatrice" ( 1974). Reprinted in Dante in America .
. . (q.v.), pp.372-389. [1983]
Holloway, Julia Bolton. "Death and the Emperor in Dante, Browning, Dickinson and Stevens." In Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer), 67-72. [Special Dante issue, q.v.] [1983]
Notes how these modern poets directly or indirectly adapted Dante's
dance-of-death scene of Emperor Trajan helping a woman (Purg.
X, 73-93) in some of their poems.
Huot, Sylvia. "Dante's Poetics of Love: Some Remarks about the Commedia and Its Vernacular Context." In Quaderni d'italianistica, IV, No. 1 (Spring), 69-88. [1983]
Offers a suggestive reading of three passages in the Commedia,
Inferno IX (and X), Purgatorio XXVII, and Paradiso
XXVIII, marking Dante's personal and poetic conversion from worldly
attachments as reflected, e.g., in his earlier Iyrics of sensual
love (the petrose), to transcendent values, from letter
to spirit, and involving obstacles, viz., some form of wall to
be overcome with external help. The interpretation recalls the
larger literary context of a lyric world of shared reality, or
shared poetic diction and system of values, from which Dante can
draw to respond to and correct the position of fellow-poets like
Guittone, Cavalcanti, and Cino, not to mention his earlier self.
In Dante's self-conscious review of his oeuvre is seen a confirmation
of the poet's conception of poetic creation as springing from
the trinitarian operation of the human mind, and at its best,
as analogically paralleling divine creativity and reflecting divine
Truth.
Iannucci, Amilcare A. "Dante e il vangelo di Nicodemo: la 'discesa di Beatrice agl'inferi.' " In Letture classensi XII, 39-60. [1983]
Suggests that Beatrice is a Christ figure not only in the Vita
Nuova and in Purgatorio XXX-XXXI, but also in Inferno
II, which has echoes of the Harrowing of Hell from the Gospel
of Nicodemus. A discussion of the Harrowing in the Middle Ages
is followed by an application of it to the episode outside the
walls of Dite in Inferno VIII and IX, and in Inferno
II, when Beatrice appears in Limbo to take Virgil out.
Kaske, R.E. "The Seven Status Ecclesiae in Purgatorio XXXII and XXXIII." In Dante, Petrarch, Boccaccio: Studies in the Italian Trecento . . . (q.v.), pp. 89-113. [1983]
Explicates, with supporting documentation, the narrated events
in these cantos as a highly imaginative allegorical dramatization
of the medieval historical scheme of the seven status ecclesiae,
or "conditions of the Church." Closely linked by a structural
parallel to the Apocalypse, Dante's two versions in successive
cantos are interpreted as distinguishing between "history"
in the mind of God and history as it unfolds in the material universe,
reflecting in turn the exegetical concept of recapitulatio.
Longfellow, Henry Wadsworth. "A History of the Italian
Language and Dialects" (1832). Reprinted in Dante in America
. . . (q.v.), pp. 35-46. [1983]
Longfellow, Henry Wadsworth. "Selected Translations
from the Divina Commedia--Purgatorio" (1871). Reprinted
in Dante in America ... (q.v.), pp. 47-51. [1983]
Lowell, James Russell. "Dante" (1876). Reprinted
in Dante in America . . . (q.v.), pp. 69-86. [1983]
Mandelbaum, Allen. " 'Ruminando e mirando': la capra di Dante." in Lettere italiane, XXXV, No. 2, 145-156. [1983]
Is concerned with the meaning of dreaming, of "sonno"
and "veglia" as part of the continuum of "pensare-vanare-ruminare-immaginare-visionare-sognare."
Dante's dreams are not prophetic--the first describes symbolically
what is happening to the pilgrim in the present, the second what
has happened in the past. They are part of a progressive concern
for greater temporal density, a move towards fewer vacant spaces--if
the pilgrim has to sleep, the poet will fill the time with dreams--which
stems from Dante's ambition to be poet of the cosmos, to comprehend
the All.
Martinez, R.L. "The Pilgrim's Answer to Bonaguinta and the Poetics of the Spirit." In Stanford Italian Review, III, No. 1 (Spring), 37-63. [1983]
Drawing openly on Mazzotta's discussion of the meeting between
the two poets in relation to Dante's poetics, the author suggests
that the principles which Dante claims guide his operations as
a poet also express his status as a creature. Augustine's trinity
in the inner man, mens, notitia, amor, is echoed in reverse
order in Canto XXIV: amor, noto, dentro. Dante's "Io
mi son un . . ." echoes God's "Ego sum qui sum"
(Exodus 3:14). The perfection of the pilgrim's language is the
most nearly adequate evidence the creature can give of the creator.
Bonagiunta's language ("issa") marks the historical
and spatial singularity of his poetry.
Mazzeo, Joseph. "Light Metaphysics in the Works of
Dante" (1960). Reprinted in Dante in America . . . (q.v.),
pp. 293-324. [1983]
Mazzoni, Jacopo. "On the Defense of the Comedy of Dante": Introduction and Summary. Translated with a critical preface by Robert L. Montgomery, Jr. Tallahassee, Florida: University Presses of Florida. vii, 149 p. front. illus. 21.5 cm. ("A Florida State University Book.") [1983]
Presents a translation of the "Proem, Introduction and Summary"
of the long Della difesa della Comedia di Dante by Jacopo
Mazzoni (1548-1598), which constitutes "a complete poetic
to surround and justify the Commedia, providing it with
an entire literary and philosophical context" and articulating
"a complete theoretical attitude toward imaginative literature."
The translation is based on the partial first edition of the Difesa
(1587), but checked against the complete second edition (1688!).
There is a Translator's Preface, with an examination of Mazzoni's
work and the circumstances of its writing, along with an Appendix
of Names, Notes, a bibliography of Selected References, and an
Index.
Mazzotta, Giuseppe. "The Language of Poetry in the Vita Nuova." In Rivista di studi italiani, I, No. 1 (June), 3-14. [1983]
Treats the Vita Nuova as a parable of poetic apprenticeship,
with Dante probing ever-equivocal signs, disguises, and masks
through which love and poetry come into being. Love and writing
are both an exploration of unknown but possible worlds. The friendship
between Guido Cavalcanti and Dante is a metaphor for intellectual
conversation, but for Cavalcanti love is contingent, for Dante
Beatrice is love. Beatrice is the point of fusion between the
signifier and the signified, as in "Tanto gentile,"
where the real world vanishes in the process of internalization,
the interplay of silence. The lover is bound to a world of pure
images and representations, where the fabric of stable references
seems on the verge of dissolving, where there is no necessary
bond between images and referents. The book ends with a visionary
venture into the future which no longer means death but the project
to write.
Mortimer, Ruth. "The Presence of Vergil in the Marcolini Dante of 1544." In Essays in Honor of James Edward Walsh on His Sixty-Fifth Birthday, edited by Hugh Amory (Cambridge, Massachusetts: The Goethe Institute of Boston and the Houghton Library), pp. 144-154. [1983]
Describes the new illustrated edition of the Commedia for
printing the commentary by Alessandro Vellutello as designed by
the Venetian printer Francesco Marcolini in 1544. Highlighted
by the author are certain changes in the woodcut illustrations
from earlier instances, especially with a new emphasis on tracking
the poets, and on mapping Dante's progress in particular. Includes
one illustration.
Musa, Mark. "The Sensual Pilgrim: Dream 1 of Purgatory." In Rivista di studi italiani, I, No. 2 (Dec.), 1-12. [1983]
Treats the first dream as a part of the narrative, an event, the
descent of the eagle, and ascent of eagle and pilgrim as a sign
of divine intervention and an assurance of ultimate success. Noting
the suggestion of the sensuous, sensual, and erotic in the three
mythological allusions and in the prayer (the noctium phantasmata),
the author asks why there should be a daily recurrence of the
hymn and of the spectacle of the serpent and angels. He suggests
that the negligent, who are outside the gate of Purgatory, need
the reassurance that they are saved which those inside get from
their constant penance, and that the dream world is where the
late repentant can be tempted without their salvation being jeopardized.
Nevin, Thomas R. "Regenerate Nature in Purgatorio XXVI." In Stanford Italian Review, III, No. 1 (Spring), 65-81. [1983]
Analyzes the similes Dante uses in the canto and their sources
and analogues: the ants from Aeneid IV, the cranes from
the Thebaid XIII, 1, the fish in Paradiso V. The
Christian interpretation of each is noted--ants as providence,
cranes as the militant brotherhood, the fish as sexual purity,
with no masculine or feminine. The author points to hermaphroditism
in connection with poetry: Guido Guinizelli is Hypsipyle in a
simile, but also Dante's "padre," and Statius speaks
of the Aeneid as "mamma" and "nutrice."
Art and reason are feminine and masculine processes which together
beget truth. Although Guido and Arnaut and the "altri miglior,"
unlike Dante, failed to subordinate aesthetic truths to philosophy,
Arnaut's forge probably represents the masculine informing power,
while his vocabulary is both "yrsuta" and "pexa,"
powerful and sweet.
Noakes, Susan. "The Double Misreading of Paolo and Francesca." In Philological Quarterly, LXII, No. 2 (Summer), 221-239. [1983]
Contends that in light of a complete reading of the Old French
Prose Lancelot the episode of Paolo and Francesca may be interpreted
as an example of misreading, viz., of how the two lovers misread
the Lancelot, with dire consequences, for (1) the prose
romance is a powerful condemnation of adultery and (2) Lancelot
himself is guilty of misinterpreting Guinivere's conventional
words (e.g., she refers to him as "ami") as a personal
declaration of love for him. Through a complete and careful reading
of the prose romance, Francesca would have understood the warning
against adultery and would have recognized that "what she
reads is literature and not life, a convention with no necessary
and direct applicability to her own 'moment.'" The author
concludes with an excursus on certain words and concepts that
Francesca misinterprets in Inferno V--punto, amore,
prima radice, libro--and their reappearance and use in spiritually
and morally correct form in the Paradiso.
Norton, Charles Eliot. "'The New Life' of Dante"
(1859). Reprinted in Dante in America . . . (q.v.), pp.52-68.
[1983]
Pellegrini, Anthony L. "American Dante Bibliography for 1982." In Dante Studies, CI, 193-223. [1983]
With brief Analyses.
Pellegrini, Anthony L. (Joint editor). See Dante, Petrarch,
Boccaccio: Studies in the Italian Trecento in Honor of Charles
S. Singleton ...
Picone, Michelangelo. "Paradiso IX: Dante, Folchetto e la diaspora trobadorica." In Medioevo romanzo, VIII, No. 1 (1981-1983), 47-89. [1983]
Offers a detailed, insightful reading of Paradiso IX which
takes account of the vast array of Provençal characters
(Folquet de Marseille, Sordello, Cunizza) and material that compose
and underlie this episode.
Pietropaolo, Domenico. "Anton Maria Biscioni's Textual Criticism of the Vita Nuova and of the Convivio." In Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer), 41-52. [Special Dante issue, q.v.] [1983]
Examines the pioneering endeavor at establishing textual precision
by Biscioni with his 1723 editions of the Vita Nuova and
Convivio, marking an important milestone in the history
of Dante criticism.
Pound, Ezra. "Hell" ( 1934). (A Review of Dante's
Inferno translated into English Triple Rhyme, by Laurence
Binyon.) Reprinted in Dante in America ... (q.v.), pp.
175-186. [1983]
Pound, Ezra. Pound's Cavalcanti: An Edition of the Translations, Notes, and Essays. By David Anderson. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press. xxxvi, 297 p. 22 cm. [1983]
Includes Pound's essay, "Cavalcanti" (pp. 203-251), originally published in The Dial (1928-29) and reprinted in his Make It New (1934), as well as Pound's translation of Cavalcanti's poems with the Italian text on facing pages. Contains ample reference to Dante in relation to Cavalcanti. Indexed.
Quinlan, Kieran. "Forsaking the Norse Mythologies: Seamus Heaney's Conversion to Dante." In Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer), 19-28. [Special Dante issue, q.v.] [1983]
Accounts for the North Irish poet's "conversion" to
Dante as a kindred spirit adaptable to his Celtic background and
cites numerous uses of Dante in Heaney's own poetry.
Raimondi, Ezio. "Tassonomie dantesche." In Dante, Petrarch, Boccaccio: Studies in the Italian Trecento ... (q.v.), pp. 19-30. [1983]
Extrapolating from Castelvetro's Sposizione of twenty-nine
cantos of the Inferno and his translation/commentary of
Aristotle's Poetics, the author discusses the sixteenth-century
critic's classification of figures and their postures and movements
in Malebolge as structural elements with the effect of visually,
rationally, and mnemonically enhancing the narrative line for
the reader, and relates Castelvetro's thinking here to the contemporary
Pierre de la Ramée's introduction of a visual component
in intellectual abstraction. Reflecting the Ramist method is Castelvetro's
focus on the important pairing of the outward eye as ancillary
to the mental eye, which is to say the intellect and imagination,
for the critical consideration of the literary artifact.
Rand, Edward Kennard. "Dante and Servius" (1914).
Reprinted in Dante in America . . . (q.v.), pp. 133-143.
[1983]
Reynolds, Barbara. "Dorothy Sayers and the Penguin Dante." In Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer), 29-39. [Special Dante issue, q.v.] [1983]
Recounts the conversion of Dorothy Sayers to the reading, study
and translation (Penguin Books) of Dante's Comedy, thanks
to her inspiring encounter in 1943 with Charles Williams' The
Figure of Beatrice.
Rodríguez-Alcalá, Hugo, and Jean-Pierre Barricelli. "Dante and Rulfo: Beyond Time through Eternity." In Hispanic Journal, V, No. 1 (Fall), 7-27. [1983]
Examine and compare Dante's Commedia and Juan Rulfo's Pedro
Páramo with respect to the concept of time obtaining
in each work. Rulfo's fictional town Comala is seen to be set
"squarely in the context of an other-worldly eternity."
Russo, Vittorio. "Paradiso XIX: similis fictio numquam facta fuit per aliquem poetam." In Dante Studies, CI, 87-110. [1983]
Examines Paradiso XIX thematically, structurally, and stylistically from the rhetorical insinuatio of the exordium to Dante's central question (dubbio) about divine justice denying salvation to those who die ignorant of Christ and without baptism, to the hopeful answer that relieves his tension given in Canto XX (vv. 130-135), but prepared for by the political invective at the end of XIX (vv. 106ff.). Although beyond human understanding, thanks to divine mercy and through gratuitous grace, there are actually many exceptions to the harsh (by human perception) divine exclusion, as exemplified by the case of Ripheus. In the invective against corrupt rulers, the poet returns stylistically to the harsh tones and rhymes of the Inferno, with high tragic effect in enhancing in turn the substantive intentionality and expressive exceptionality of Canto XIX. The author finds Dante's claim of originality and inventiveness (vv. 7-9) amply justified.
Santayana, George. "Dante" (1910). Reprinted
in Dante in America . . . (q.v.), pp.116-132. [1983]
Silverstein, Theodore. "On the Genesis of De Monarchia,
Il, v" (1938). Reprinted in Dante in America . . . (q.v.),
pp. 187-218. [1983]
Singleton, Charles S. "Dante's Allegory" (1950).
Reprinted in Dante in America ... (q.v.), pp. 244-255.
[1983]
Sowell, Madison U. "A Bibliography of the Dantean Simile to 1981." In Dante Studies, CI, 167-180. [1983]
Lists 147 items from 1707 to 1981 dealing with Dante's use of
the simile, preceded by introductory remarks which point out the
integrity of this rhetorical figure structurally, stylistically,
philosophically, metaphysically to the poet's cosmic vision and
therefore stress the need for much further study of the Dantean
simile.
Sowell, Madison U. "The Niven-Pournelle Dante: A Twentieth-Century Odyssey through Hell." In Studies in Medievalism, Il, No. 3 (Summer), 73-78. [Special Dante issue, q.v.] [1983]
Discusses the novel Inferno (1976), by science-fiction
writers Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle, as a twentieth-century
odyssey through Hell, based on Dante's poem but in a modern vein
reflecting the skeptics' view disallowing "any traditional
concept of Hell in today's world."
Stephany, William A. "Biblical Allusions to Conversion in Purgatorio XXI." In Stanford Italian Review, III, No. 3 (Fall), 141-162. [1983]
Relates the episode of Statius' attempted obeisance to Virgil
in Purgatorio XXI, 130 ff., to the noli me tangere
interchange between Mary Magdalen and Jesus on Easter morning
(John 20:17). In light of the larger significance of the Statius
episode and the clustering of other Biblical allusions in Canto
XXI and at the end of XX, the parallel of Statius kneeling before
Virgil and Mary kneeling before Jesus establishes a context for
the subsequent discussion of Statius' conversion and his now perfected
spiritual state. Other biblical allusions in Canto XXI (episode
of the Samaritan woman and the disciples on the road to Emmaus),
as well as at the end of XX, not to mention specific echoes of
Psalm 113 in general, are all seen paradigmatically to reinforce
the episode of Statius as Dante's model convert. A concomitant
theme cited is that of misinterpretation followed by metanoia
and rectification, evidencing further Dante's figural sophistication
in treating the whole episode.
Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer), [special issue:] "Dante in the Modern World," edited by Kathleen Verduin. 114 p., plus Supplement, pp. 115-158. [1983]
Contains thirteen short Dantean pieces, including three book reviews,
all registered separately by author in this bibliography.
Sturm-Maddox, Sara. "Petrarch's Serpent in the Grass: The Fall as Subtext in the Rime sparse." In Journal of Medieval and Renaissance Studies, XIII, No. 2 (Fall), 213-226. [1983]
Points out antecedents in Dante's Purgatorio VIII 97-100,
and XXX, 28-30, and Paradiso XXXII, 4-6, for passages in
Petrarch's Sonnet 99, Canzone 126, and Canzone 366, respectively,
in the context of the article's general thesis.
Tate, Allen. "The Symbolic Imagination" (1952).
Reprinted in Dante in America . . . (q.v.), pp. 256-273.
[1983]
Taylor, Karla Terese. "Chaucer Reads the Divine Comedy." In Dissertation Abstracts International, XLIV, No. 5 (November), 1449A. [1983]
Doctoral dissertation, Stanford University, 1983. 405 p. (Through
Dantean echoes, esp. of Inf. V, in Troilus and Criseyde,
Chaucer seems to question the capacity of human poetry to report
transcendence, as Dante seeks to do.)
Taylor, Karla Terese. "A Text and Its Afterlife: Dante and Chaucer." In Comparative Literature, XXXV, No. 1 (Winter), 1-20. [1983]
Examines the complementary notions of authorial intent and the
varying reception of an author's works by later generations through
an investigation and comparison of Inferno V and Troilus
and Criseyde. Dante is seen as seeking to prevent misreading
of his text by creating an ideal reader (cf. Par. II, 1-6,
e.g.) to conform to his own authorial intent. But, as the author
illustrates through the example of Troilus, Chaucer demonstrates
the vanity of this by reading the Commedia in a way contrary
to Dante's intended idealistic, eschatalogical vision.
Vallone, Aldo. "Jacopo della Lana interprete di Dante." in Dante, Petrarch, Boccaccio: Studies in the Italian Trecento . . . (q.v.), pp. 151-181. [1983]
Offers a critical examination and assessment, with a number of
illustrative passages, of the Sposizione (c. 1324-1328)
of Jacopo della Lana as one who, while among the earliest critical
readers of Dante's poem and therefore still very much of the contemporary
medieval mind-set, stands out for his high competence, broad vision,
and firm control of the poem as a whole. In endeavoring to prepare
the reader for the Commedia, Jacopo reflects a conception
of poetry as "verità rivestita dal meraviglioso"
and a poetics, in short, that will engage to varying degree subsequent
commentators from the Ottimo to Landino.
Verduin, Kathleen. "Dante and the Sin of Satan: Augustinian Patterns in Inferno XXXIV, 22-27." In Quaderni d'italianistica, IV, No. 2 (Autunno), 208-217. [1983]
Through relevant passages in Augustine and the Augustinian mode
of thought underlying the Commedia, the author examines
the similarity between the Pilgrim's unusual state ("Io non
morì, e non rimasi vivo") in Inferno XXXIV,
22-27, and that of Lucifer the fallen angel, concluding that the
Pilgrim's experience suggests "a union and commingling with
the Satanic essence." Furthermore, this episode is linked
in a diametrically opposed manner to that in Paradiso XXXIII,
97-103, where the Pilgrim is again caught up in a transfixed state,
but here the "vision is one of love rather than fear, and
the union is one of life rather than death."
Verduin, Kathleen. "Dante in the Modern World (Editorial Introduction)." In Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer), 6-13. [Special Dante issue, q.v.] [1983]
Reviews the varying but increasingly positive fortunes of Dante
in literature and art of the last two centuries and observes that,
far from suffering antiquation, the poet has, in the modern imagination,
been all things to all men.
Verduin, Kathleen, editor, "Dante in the Modern World."
Special issue of Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer),
q.v., above. [1983]
Vickers, Nancy. "Seeing Is Believing: Gregory, Trajan, and Dante's Art." In Dante Studies, CI, 67-85. [1983]
Documents scripturally, exegetically, and iconographically the
importance of the subtext for reading Dante's Commedia,
and more specifically the Trajan/Gregory story in Purgatorio
X, 73-93. Not only does the poet make such textual demands on
his reader, but he also reflects the same in the "visibile
parlare" of his poetic bas-reliefs representing the familiar
legend. Comes with five illustrations.
Welle, John P. "Fellini's Use of Dante in La dolce vita." In Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer), 53-66. [Special Dante issue, q.v.] [1983]
Focuses on the gesture of greeting around which Federico Fellini's
film is constructed, linking this motif as vehicle for revealing
aspects of the characters with Dante's Vita Nuova, in which
greeting is also paramount.
Werge, Thomas. "Dante and Modern Literature: A Review of Scholarship 1960-1981." In Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer), Supplement, 115-157. [Special Dante issue, q.v.] [1983]
Surveys, selectively, somewhat over "two decades of commentary
on Dante and modern literature or the uses modern writers have
made of Dante's work," but limited to the nineteenth and
twentieth centuries. The items, mostly in English, are treated
under six headings: I. Modern Literature (General), II. European
Literature, III. English and Irish Literature, IV. American Literature,
V. Other National Literatures, VI. Drama and Film.
Whallon, William. Inconsistencies: Studies in the New Testament, the "Inferno," "Othello," and "Beowulf." [Cambridge, England:] D.S. Brewer; [Totowa, New Jersey:] Biblio. 107 p. 24.5 cm. [1983]
Contains a chapter entitled "Does the Inferno have
one higher sense, or three, or none?" (pp. 42-67 and 99-100)
in which the author, noting the incompatibility of Dante's varying
scheme of interpretation vis-à-vis those of Augustine and
Aquinas and even inconsistencies with Dante's thought as well,
the author examines the situation in the first cantica
of the Commedia. He summarizes his complex argument as
an answer to the question thus: "In addition to its literal
sense--its gallery of portraits from the afterlife--the Commedia
may be held to have a pervasive moral sense in its diagrammatic
arrangements of sins and virtues. It may also be held to have
a pervasive anagogical sense in its continuous allusion back to
the life on earth; but the anagogical is continuous with, not
distinct from, the literal sense, for last thoughts from this
world have gone with the soul into the next. The 34th canto of
the Inferno has also an allegorical (typological) sense:
the group Lucifer, Judas, Brutus and Cassius, implies a grouping
of God, Christ, and Caesar, who are each the supreme being. So
there is but a single higher sense--the moral--if the anagogical,
as being continuous with the literal, is not counted, and if the
allegorical (typological), as being found in the 34th canto only,
is not counted either; but to count all three would be fair. Our
attention should though be given elsewhere. That the archfelons
are damnable beyond all others both as judged by the ethical nature
of their sin, and as judged from those they sinned against--this
combining of primary reasons is the best piece of workmanship
in literature" (pp. 99-100).
Wilkins, Ernest Hatch. "Dante and the Mosaics of Bel
San Giovanni" (1927). Reprinted in Dante in America
. . . (q.v.), pp. 144-159. [1983]
Wright, Dorena Allen. "Hawthorne's Blithedale Romance." In Explicator, XLI, No. 4 (Summer), 28-29. [1983]
Cites Hawthorne's allusion in Blithedale Romance to "Dante's
ghostly forest" as another foreshadowing of Zenobia's suicide.
Yarian, Stanley O. "The Twentieth-Century Role of the Hell of St. Francis of Assisi and Dante." In Soundings, LXVI, No. 3 (Fall), 331-347. [1983]
Examines from a contemporary perspective the medieval understanding
of the function of Hell and Purgatory and the particular and diverse
ways in which St. Francis and Dante represent the essence of the
thought on these two realms. For both individuals Hell and Purgatory
are experiences which open the way for self-knowledge, for probing
the human and divine depths of man, and, as such, they can be
"appropriated even today as a symbol that opens us to an
essential dimension of Christian self-understanding."
Zupan, Patricia Jean. " 'Per seguir virtute e canoscenza': The Significance of Ulysses' Final Journey." In Dissertation Abstracts International XLIV, No. 3 (September), 749A. [1983]
Doctoral dissertation, Indiana University, 1983. 156 p. (Viewing
Ulysses' voyage as an ungraced, therefore, unsuccessful, pagan
attempt for spiritual regeneration, the author aligns that quest
for virtue and knowledge with Dante- pilgrim's first stage toward
knowledge of God.)
The Divine Comedy A new verse translation by C.H. Sisson. Foreword to the American edition by Thomas G. Bergin; introduction, commentary, notes and bibliography by David H. Higgins. Chicago: Regnery Gateway, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 133-134, 156, and 167.) Reviewed by:
David Anderson, in Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer),
87-96; Thomas G. Bergin, in Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2
(Spring), 261-269.
The Divine Comedy of Dante Alighieri. [Inferno] A verse translation, with introduction and commentary by Allen Mandelbaum. Drawings by Barry Moser. Berkeley-Los Angeles-London: University of California Press, 1980. (See Dante Studies, XCIX, 173-174 and 196, C, 156-157 and 167, and CI, 215 and 222.) Reviewed by:
David Anderson, in Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer), 87-96; John Freccero, in Boston Review, VIII (June), 24-25.
The Divine Comedy of Dante Alighieri. [Purgatorio] . . . 1982. (See Dante Studi, CI, 215.) Reviewed by: David Anderson, in Studies in Medievalism, No. 3 (Summer), 87-96; Thomas G. Bergin, in Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2 (Spring), 261-269; A.R.C. Duncan, in Queen's Quarterly, IV, 1218-1221;
John Freccero, in Boston Review, VIII (June), 24-25.
Dante's Purgatory. Translation, with notes and commentary, by Mark Musa. Bloomington and London: Indiana University Press, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 134 and 157.) Reviewed by:
Thomas G. Bergin, in Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2 (Spring),
261-269; Madison U. Sowell, in Speculum. LVIII, No. 2 (April),
448-450.
Dante's "Rime." Translated by Patrick S. Diehl. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1979. (See Dante Studies, XCVIII, 160 and 176, and XCIX, 196.) Reviewed by:
Thomas G. Bergin, in Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2 (Spring),
261-269.
Dante in Hell: The "De vulgari eloquentia." Introduction, Text, Translation, and Commentary by Warman Welliver. Ravenna: A. Longo Editore, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 134.) Reviewed by:
Susan J. Noakes, in Speculum, LVIII, No. 2 (April), 540-542.
Literature in the Vernacular. Translated with an introduction by Sally Purcell. [Manchester:] Carcanet New Press Limited, 1981. 84 p. 20 cm. Translation of the De vulgari eloquentia and some selections of poets mentioned by Dante. Reviewed by:
[Anon.] in Choice, XX, No. 7 (Mar.-Aug.), 994.
Anderson, William. Dante the Maker. London, Boston, and Henley: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1980. (See Dante Studies, CI, 194-195 and 215-216; also c, 157.) Reviewed by:
Thomas G. Bergin, in Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2 (Spring),
261-269.
Arnaut Daniel. The Poetry of Arnaut Daniel. Edited and translated by James J. Wilhelm. New York and London: Garland Publishing, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 135.) Reviewed by:
Emily Albu Hanawalt, in Speculum, LVIII, No. 4 (Oct.),
1026-1027.
Atti del Convegno Internazionale di Studi Danteschi, a cura del Comune di Ravenna e della Società Dantesca Italiana (Ravenna, 10-12 sett. 1971). Ravenna: Longo Editore, 1979. x, 275 p. 24 cm. Contains 12 pieces by Contini, De Robertis, Ageno, Ricci, Pézard, Mazzoni, Petrocchi, Vallone, Dionisotti, Chiarini, Vasoli, and Migliorini Fissi, introduced by F. Mazzoni. Reviewed by:
Joseph Chierici, in Italian Quarterly, XXIV, No. 92 (Spring),
113-117.
Beltrami, Pietro G. Metrica, poetica, metrica dantesca. Pisa: Pacini Editore, 1981. 163 p. (Biblioteca degli studi mediolatini e volgari. Nuova serie, VI.) Reviewed by:
Joseph A. Barber, in MLN, XCVIII, No. 1 (Jan.), 140-144.
Boyde, Patrick. Dante Philomythes and Philosopher: Man in the Cosmos. Cambridge, England, and New York: Cambridge University Press, 1981. viii, 408 p. Reviewed by:
James L. Miller, in Speculum, LVIII, No. 1 (Jan.), 150-152.
Cambridge Readings in Dante's Comedy. Edited by Kenelm Foster and Patrick Boyde. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1981. Contains 10 essays by P. McNair, P. Boyde, P. Boitani, U. Limentani, R. Kirkpatrick, J. Davies, P. Dronke, K. Foster, J. Cremona, and P. Shaw. Reviewed by:
Philip R. Berk, in Italica, LX, No. 4 (Winter), 367-369.
Chiampi, James T. Shadowy Prefaces: Conversion and Writing in the "Divine Comedy" Ravenna: Longo Editore, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 138.) Reviewed by:
Mark Davie, in Modern Language Review, LXXVIII, Part 2 (April), 466-468;
Madison U. Sowell, in Forum Italicum, XVII, No. 2 (Fall),
295-296.
Costa, Dennis. Irenic Apocalypse: Some Uses of Apocalyptic in Dante, Petrarch and Rabelais. Saratoga, California: Anma Libri, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 139.) Reviewed by:
Susan J. Noakes, in Speculum, LVIII, No. 2 (April), 445-448.
Ellis, Steve. Dante and English Poetry: Shelley to T.S. Eliot. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1983. 280 p. Reviewed by:
Martin Bidney, in Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer),
103-107.
Elwert, Wilhelm Theodor. Die italienische Literatur des Mittelalters Dante, Petrarca, Boccaccio. Munich: Francke, 1980. 292 p. 19 cm. (Uni-Taschenbücher, 1035.) Chapter 3, the longest, is on Dante. Reviewed by:
Louis R. Rossi, in Speculum, LVIII, No. 1 (Jan.), 170-172.
Fallani, Giovanni. Dante moderno. Ravenna: Longo Editore, 1979. 158 p. illus., 2 pls. 21 cm. Reviewed by:
Gustavo Costa, in Romance Philology, XXXVII, No. 2 (Nov.),
251-254.
Ferrucci, Franco. The Poetics of Disguise: The Autobiography of the Work in Homer, Dante, and Shakespeare. Translated by Ann Dunnigan. Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press, 1980. (See Dante Studies, XCIX, 180-182.) Reviewed by:
William J. Kennedy, in MLN, XCVIII, No. 1 (Jan.), 139-140.
Fortin, E.L. Dissidence et philosophie au moyen age: Dante et ses antécédents. Montréal: Bellarmin; Paris: J. Vrin, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 143 and 158.) Reviewed by:
Christopher J. Ryan, in Speculum, LVIII, No. 2 (April),
463-468.
Fowlie, Wallace. A Reading of Dante's Inferno. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 143-144.) Reviewed by:
Thomas G. Bergin, in Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2 (Spring), 261-269.
Mark Davie, in Modern Language Review, LXXVIII, Part 2 (April), 466-468;
Corinna Salvadori Lonergan, in Italica, LX, No. 4 (Winter), 369-370;
Susan J. Noakes, in Speculum, LVIII, No. 2 (April), 540-542.
Franco, Charles. La Beatrice di Dante: un'interpretazione psicanalitica. Poggibonsi: Antonio Lalli Editore, 1981. 203 p. Reviewed by:
John Charles Nelson, in Italica, LX, No. 4 (Winter), 370-372;
Madison U. Sowell, in Forum Italicum, XVII, No. 2 (Fall),
297-298.
Girardi, Enzo Noè. Studi su Dante. Brescia: Edizioni del Moretto, 1980. 253 p. Reviewed by:
Mario Trovato, in Italica, LX, No. 3 (Autumn), 276-277.
Hollander, Robert. Studies in Dante. Ravenna: Longo Editore, 1980. (See Dante Studies, XCIX, 183-184, c, 158, and CI, 218.) Reviewed by:
John J. Guzzardo, in Speculum, LVIII, No. 1 (Jan.), 180-183.
Holmes, George. Dante. New York: Hill and Wang, 1980. Reviewed by:
Thomas G. Bergin, in Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2 (Spring),
261-269.
Iannucci, Amilcare A. "Autoesegesi dantesca: la tecnica dell'`episodio parallelo' nella Commedia." In Lettere italiane, XXXIII, No. 3 (July-Sept. 1983), 305-328. (See Dante Studies, C, 145.) Reviewed by:
Gabriele Muresu, in Rassegna della letteratura italiana,
LXXXVII, Nos. 1-2 (Jan.-Aug.), 170-171.
Kirkpatrick, Robin. Dante's "Paradiso" and the Limitation of Modern Criticism: A Study of Style and Poetic Theory. Cambridge-London-New York-Melbourne: Cambridge University Press, 1978. (See Dante Studies, XCVIII, 184-185, also 178 and 189.) Reviewed by:
Joseph Chierici, in Italian Quarterly, XXIV, No. 94 (Fall),
112-113.
Lipking, Lawrence. The Life of the Poet: Beginning and Ending Poetic Careers. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 147.) Reviewed by:
May G. Hamilton, in Canadian Review of Comparative Literature,
X, No. 3 (Sept.), 407-410.
Mazzaro, Jerome. The Figure of Dante: An Essay on the "Vita Nuova." Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 148.) Reviewed by:
Teodolinda Barolini, in Renaissance Quarterly, XXXVI, No. 1 (Spring), 75-77;
Thomas G. Bergin, in Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2 (Spring), 261-269;
John A. Scott, in Modern Language Review, LXXVIII, Part
3 (July), 724-726.
Nolan, Barbara. The Gothic Visionary Perspective. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1977. Contains a chapter on Dante's Vita Nuova (pp. 84-123) and further reference to Dante. (See Dante Studies, XCVI, 230-231.) Reviewed by:
Susanna Peters Coy, in Romance Philology, XXXVI, No. 3
(Feb.), 452-458.
Picone, Michelangelo. "Vita Nuova" e tradizione romanza. Padova: Liviana Editore, 1979. (See Dante Studies, XCVIII, 171-172.) Reviewed by:
Carla De Bellis, in Quaderni d'italianistica, IV, No. 2
(Autumn), 235-236.
Reynolds, Mary T. Joyce and Dante: The Shaping Imagination. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 151.) Reviewed by:
Morris Beja, in Forum Italicum, XVII, No. 1 (Spring), 123-125;
Thomas G. Bergin, in Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2 (Spring), 261-269;
Gene Dinielli, in Studies in Medievalism, II, No. 3 (Summer), 108-112;
Wallace Fowlie, in Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2 (Spring),
xxx and xxxii.
Richards, Earl Jeffrey. Dante and the "Roman de la Rose": An Investigation into the Vernacular Narrative Context of the "Commedia." Tübingen: Max Niemeyer, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 151.) Reviewed by:
Richard H. Lansing, in Speculum, LVIII, No. 3 (July), 801-803.
Rolfs, Daniel. The Last Cross: A History of the Suicide Theme in Italian Literature. Ravenna: Longo Editore, 1981. (See Dante Studies, C, 152.) Reviewed by:
Fiora A. Bassanese, in Italica, LX, No. 3 (Autumn), 290-291;
Michael Caesar, in Modern Language Review, LXXVIII, Part 2 (April), 468-470;
Joy Hambuechen Potter, in Forum Italicum, XVII, No. 2 (Fall),
292-294.
Slade, Carole, editor. Approaches to Teaching Dante's "Divine Comedy." New York: The Modern Language Association of America, 1982. (See Dante Studies, CI, 211 and 219.) Reviewed by:
Thomas G. Bergin, in Sewanee Review, XCI, No. 2 (Spring), 261-269;
Erminio Braidotti, in College Literature, X, No. 2, 202-204;
Beno Weiss, in Modern Language Journal, LXVII, No. 2 (Summer),
197-198.
Ruggiers, Paul G., editor. Versions of Medieval Comedy. Edited and with an introduction ... Norman, Oklahoma: University of Oklahoma Press, 1977. Contains Howard H. Schless, "Dante: Comedy and Conversion," pp. 135-149. (See Dante Studies, XCVI, 234 and 250-251.) Reviewed by:
John L. Grigsby, in Romance Philology, XXXVI, No. 4 (May),
584-591.
Wilhelm, James J. Il Miglior Fabbro: The Cult of the Difficult in Daniel, Dante, and Pound. Orono, Maine: National Poetry Foundation, University of Maine at Orono, 1982. (See Dante Studies, CI, 214.) Reviewed by:
Julia Bolton Holloway, in Studies in Medievalism, II, No.
3 (Summer), 67-72.
The World of Dante: Essays on Dante and His Times. Edited by Cecil Grayson. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press, 1980. 252 p. illus.(8) Reviewed by:
John J. Guzzardo, in Speculum, LVIII, No. 1 (Jan.), 180-183.
]
Cervigni, Dino S. "Dante's Poetry of Dreams." In Pacific Coast Philology, XVII, No. 1-2 (November 1982), 24-30.
Considers the three dreams of the Purgatorio as integral
parts of the Pilgrim's journey to knowledge and salvation, insofar
as they mediate, as examples of visio immaginativa or spiritualis,
between the knowledge gained through the external senses (visio
corporalis, Inferno) and that which comes from the intellect
(visio intellectualis, Paradiso) in the Augustinian formulation.
Chierici, Joseph. "Il 'buon citarista' e il 'soave medico' nel XX del Paradiso (vv. 23-30, 142)." In L'Alighieri, XXII, No. 2 (Aug.-Dec. 1981),12-30.
Examines the two images in light of Patristic commentary linking
Christ to the traditional metaphors of musical harmony and the
"good physician" and proceeds to discuss the problem
of the salvation of the two pagans Trajan and Ripheus. The author
concludes that in the case of Ripheus Dante had recourse to St.
Thomas' concept of penitential baptism (Summa Theol. III.lxvi.2).
Cowan, Bainard. "Dante's 'novella Tebe.' " In Comparatist, VI, No. 1 (1982), 16-23.
Discusses Dante's use of Thebes as the archetypal city of civic
discord and violence and concludes that the depiction of Pisa
as a modern Thebes is typical of the poet's use of classical mythology
"to reveal basic patterns of human action in his contemporary
surroundings."
Emerick, Betsy. "Auerbach and Gramsci on Dante: Criticism and Ideology." In Carte italiane, I (1979-80), 9-22.
Compares the two critics' readings of Inferno X and argues
that while each was conditioned by the political circumstances
of personal exile--Auerbach in Istanbul during the war, Gramsci
in prison under the Fascist dictatorship--each promoted contrasting
views of the role of the literary critic. Auerbach's methodology
is found to be more "evangelistic," Gramsci's less motivated
by ideological considerations.
Kelly, Craig. "Law, Justice and Providence in Paradiso VI." In Carte italiane, I (1979-80), 1-8.
Argues that the interpretation of the concepts of divine and terrestrial
justice, hinted at in the closing lines of the Monarchia,
is fully developed in Paradiso VI.
Matthews, J. Chesley. "H.W. Longfellow's Interest in Dante." In Papers Presented at the Longfellow Conference, April 1-3, 1982. Coordinated by the National Park Service, Longfellow National Historical Park (U.S. Printing Office, 1982), 47-58.
Chronicles Longfellow's long association with Dante's works, citing
various stages that eventually led him to translate the whole
Divine Comedy, not to mention incorporating echoes of the
poem in his own works.
Niven, Larry, and Jerry Pournelle. Inferno. New York: Pocket Books, 1976. 192 p. Also, London: Alan Wingate, 1977.
Inscribed "For Dante Alighieri," this science-fiction novel, a 20th-century odyssey through Hell, hews closely to the structure of Dante's Inferno, but is cast in modern vein and spirit. (See M.U. Sowell, "The Niven-Pournelle Dante . . . ," above, main section, Studies.)
Picone, Michelangelo. "Dante e il mito di Narciso: dal Roman de la Rose alla Commedia." In Romanische Forschungen, LXXXIX (1977), 382-397.
Examines the symbolism of the myth in both poems and finds that
Dante builds on meanings developed by both Guillaume de Lorris
and Jean de Meun. He suggests, in particular, that in the cantos
of the Earthly Paradise Dante establishes imagistic parallels
with traditional aspects of the Narcissus story in order to present
Dante as the antithesis of Narcissus. Dante is seen, in his quest
as lover to reach the beloved Beatrice, to avoid repeating the
tragic fate of his mythological counterpart.
Pipa, Arshi. "Ironia cavalcantiana." In L'Alighieri, XXI, No. 2 (1980), 47-56.
Contends that Cavalcanti parodies a number of verses in the Vita
Nuova, in particular "Tanto gentile e tanto onesta,"
as well as verses by Guinizelli, in an attempt to overturn their
meaning.
Rossi, Albert. " 'A l'ultimo suo': Paradiso XXX and Its Virgilian Context." In Studies in Medieval and Renaissance History, New Series, IV (1981), 39-88.
Contends that Dante conceives of Henry VII in the Commedia
as recapitulating the expectation, mission, and ultimate fate
of Marcellus as he is presented by Virgil in Aeneid VI,
but with a difference. Although each poet prophesies the coming
of an ideal imperial savior and describes the personal failure
of his enterprise through an untimely and unexpectedly early death,
Dante's vision of Henry's eventual seat in the White Rose (Par.
XXX, 133 ff.) "corrects" the inadequacy of the Virgilian
vision by attaching to Henry the idea of Christian Hope. The connection
depends in part on the numerical symmetry of the allusion to Marcellus
(Manibus, oh, date lilia plenis) and the reference to Henry's
seat in the thirtieth cantos of the Purgatorio and Paradiso,
respectively.
Ryan, Christopher. "Virgil's Wisdom in the Divine Comedy." In Medievalia et Humanistica,
IX, (1982),1-38.
Contends that although Virgil is correctly regarded as an embodiment
of human reason, his wisdom is subject to a number of limitations
of which he is only dimly aware. The author examines Virgil's
shortcomings as a guide before the Gates of Dis and in the fifth
trench of Malebolge, but concentrates on what he conceives to
be the poet's greater failure with respect to preparing Dante
properly for his reunion with Beatrice in the Earthly Paradise.
Virgil, he argues, leads Dante erroneously to expect from Beatrice
a warm welcome, rather than a rebuke, which demonstrates his insufficient
knowledge of the necessity of an act of personal repentance on
Dante's part at this point in Purgatory. What prevents Virgil
from leading Dante to "full purification" is his being
tainted by "original sin." The three major Virgilian
allusions in Purgatorio XXX, closely analyzed, are seen
to point up the differences between the pagan and Christian world-views,
especially concerning the nature of life after death, ultimately
to demonstrate the degree of Virgil's limitations with respect
to Beatrice.
Fergusson, Francis. Literary Landmarks: Essays on the Theory and Practice of Literature. New Brunswick, New Jersey: Rutgers University Press, 1975. (See Dante Studies, CI, 220-221.) Reviewed by:
Ray Ellenwood, in Canadian Review of Comparative Literature,
V, No. 2 (Spring), 231-232.
State University of New York at Binghamton
Binghamton, New York