This bibliography is intended to include all the Dante translations published in this country in 1990 and all Dante studies and reviews published in 1990 that are in any sense American. The latter criterion is construed to include foreign reviews of American publications pertaining to Dante. The listing of reviews in general is selective, particularly in the case of studies bearing only peripherally on Dante.
Items cited from Dissertation Abstracts International are generally registered without further abstracting, since the titles tend to be self-explanatory. Items not recorded in the bibliographies for previous years are entered as addenda to the present list.
Generally, the citation of an individual study from a collected volume representing several authors is given in brief, while the main entry of the volume is listed with full bibliographical data in its alphabetical order. Issues of this journal under the former title Annual Report of the Dante Society continue to be cited in the short form of Report, with volume number.
For their invaluable assistance in the preparation of this bibliography
and its annotations my special thanks go to the following graduate
students--past and present--at the University of Wisconsin-Madison:
Fabian Alfie, Edward Hagman, Gerald NeCastro, Pauline Scott, Elizabeth
Serrin, Tonia Bernardi Triggiano, Scott Troyan, Scott Visovatti,
and to Adriano Comollo of Brigham Young University and Mary Refling
of New York University.
Dante Alighieri. Dante's "Il Convivio" (The Banquet). Translated by Richard H. Lansing. New York and London: Garland Publishing. xxxi, 274 p. (Garland Library of Medieval Literature, Volume 65, Series B.) [1990]
The translation is based on Maria Simonelli's critical edition
(Bologna: Pàtron, 1966) and contains an Introduction ("The
Convivio in Dante's Life," "Artistic Achievement,"
"Sources and Influences," "Editorial Policy for
This Translation"), a Select Bibliography, Notes, and an
Index.
Boccaccio, Giovanni. The Life of Dante (Trattatello in Laude di Dante). Translated by Vincenzo Zin Bollettino. New York and London, Garland Publishing. lxii, 97 p. (Garland Library of Medieval Literature, Volume 40, Series B.) [1990]
The translation is based on Pier Giorgio Ricci's edition in Tutte
le opere di Giovanni Boccaccio, vol. III (Verona: Mondadori,
1965) and contains an Introduction ("The Life of the Author
before the Composition of The Life of Dante," "Artistic
Achievement: Forms of The Life of Dante," "Sources:
Biography in the Middle Ages," "Sources: Dante the Man,"
"Sources: Dante the Poet," "Dante and Boccaccio's
Influences on Realism and Vernacular Writing," "Editorial
Policy for This Translation"), a Select Bibliography, and
Notes.
Shapiro, Marianne. De Vulgari Eloquentia: Dante's Book of Exile. Lincoln and London: University of Nebraska Press. xiv, 277 p. (Regents Studies in Medieval Culture.) [1990]
Shapiro discusses Dante's treatise as the distinctive product
of the poet's exile, a universal statement on language that coincides
with and complements his conception of Empire. The volume includes
consideration of the late medieval grammarians--the modistae:
Martin de Dacia, Boethius de Dacia, Johannes de Dacia, and Michel
de Marbais--and their influence on Dante, as well as a new English
translation of De vulgari eloquentia, which is based on
Pier Vincenzo Mengaldo's edition (Padova: Antenore, 1968). Contents:
Preface; Bibliographical Note; Introduction: Dante's Book of Exile;
De Vulgari Eloquenia: A Translation; Vernacular Backgrounds;
The Rules of Sir Raimon Vidal: A Translation; On the Art of Composing
Poems [De la doctrina de compondre dictatz]: A Translation;
Dante and the Grammarians; Conclusion: Problems and Perspectives;
Notes; Bibliography; Index.
Ahern, John. "Nudi Grammantes: The Grammar and Rhetoric of Deviation in Inferno XV." In Romanic Review, LXXXI, No. 4 (November), 466-486. [1990]
Argues that Dante's portrayal of the sodomites owes a debt to
Boncompagno da Signa, who in Rhetorica Novissima (1235)
ridicules medieval grammarians for "subjecting civil laws
to Priscian's rules." In an earlier tract (1215) Boncompagno
had already put John of Salisbury's pun on Lucan's phrase "nudi
Garamantes" to good use in his polemics against scholars
who considered rhetoric to be a subdivision of grammar. Ahern
believes that Dante must have been familiar with Boncompagno's
witticism, and he cites several instances in the canto where moral
perversion is linked with linguistic perversion. "All the
homosexual literati whom he placed in Inferno XV are 'nudi
grammantes,'" he argues, whose "deviant desire is concealed
behind and inadvertently expressed in their language."
Ahern, John. "The Reader on the Piazza: Verbal Duels in Dante's Vita Nuova." In Texas Studies in Literature and Language, XXXII, No. 1 (Spring), 18-39. [1990]
Dante reconciles the contradictory continuity of social and literary
texts as his composition "Donne ch'avete" embraces both
spoken and written paradigms of thirteenth-century Italy. While
the common element of the verbal duel occasions the poem, Dante's
deeper understanding of the dynamics of written poetic composition
seeks not a physical response from his lady but an invisible response
from his reader. As can be detected from its very first verse
"Donne ch'avete" looks to a new and larger audience
for poetry.
Ahern, John. "Troping the Fig: Inferno XV 66." In Lectura Dantis, VI (Spring), 80-91. [1990]
The familiar phrase "dolce fico" of Brunetto Latini's
prophecy to Dante reveals a powerful trope when the language of
Inferno XV is examined in the context of medieval understandings
of grammar and rhetoric. Gender ambiguity in Brunetto's use of
the word "fico" which means both the fig tree and the
fruit and his substitution of the masculine form over "fica"
suggest a certain "ungrammaticality" in his speech--a
linguistic sign representative of his sin. Dante constructs a
transumption whereby a series of meanings comment upon the sin
of sodomy and the tradition of grammar and rhetoric.
Allan, Mowbray. "Response to Teodolinda Barolini." In MLN, CV, No. 1 (January), 144-146. [1990]
The question is whether a text can generate an ontological existence.
Believing that it does not, then it follows Dante cannot cause
his readers hope for Virgil's salvation when it seems clearly
contradictory to Christian theology. In fact, we might even find
we are more likely to reject the possibility of Virgil's salvation
because we are made more exacting connoisseurs of justice as readers
than as citizens. (For Barolini's note, see below.)
Arbery, Glenn Cannon. "Dante in Bardstown: Allen Tate's Guide to Southern Exile." In Thought: A Review of Culture and Idea, LXV, No. 256 (March), 93-107. [1990]
The presence of Dante in the poetry of Allen Tate is not an overbearing
influence but rather a mode of symbolic imagination achieved by
the poet with difficulty. Arbery traces this Dantean mode as found
in Tate's poem "The Swimmers."
Ardissino, Erminia. "I Canti liturgici nel Purgatorio dantesco." In Dante Studies, CVIII, 39-65. [1990]
Examines the hymns from the liturgy found in Purgatorio
and studies how their significance in the original ecclesiastical
context is transferred to and intensified in Dante's Comedy.
"Nelle brevi citazioni Dante mette in opera una tecnica allusiva
che arricchisce il testo del poema, così come a sua volta
il poema arricchisce e commenta il testo sacro o l'inno. Si attua
una simbiosi tra testo sacro e testo poetico, l'uno chiosa l'altro
in modo che i due sistemi, sacro e poetico, divengono complici
di uno stesso messaggio."
Ascoli, Albert Russell. "'Neminem ante nos': Historicity and Authority in the De vulgari eloquentia." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 186-231. [1990]
It is tempting to read Dante's seemingly minor texts, that is
to say the Vita nuova, the Convivio and the De
vulgari eloquentia as texts subservient to the Divine Comedy.
This approach, however, overlooks possibilities for understanding
how Dante employed the "minor texts" for constructing
a personal and historical authority for himself in a culture deeply
concerned with the nature of authority.
Baldassaro, Lawrence. "Dante's Hardened Heart: The Cocytus Cantos." In Lectura Dantis Newberryana... (q. v.), pp. 3-20. [1990]
Baldassaro examines the figure of the pilgrim in Cocytus to explain
his unusual behavior there, suggesting that he is mirroring the
sin of betrayal through his reactions to the other sinners. Baldassaro
examines Dante's unclear motives in kicking Bocca degli Abati
and concludes that the Pilgrim is mirroring the sin being punished
as a recognition of his own potential for sin. Baldassaro then
analyzes the Pilgrim's meeting with Ugolino and examines the Poet's
invective against Pisa at the end of the episode. Again, Baldassaro
dismisses previous explanations, noting that Dante is calling
for the destruction of an entire city--sinners and innocents--for
the death of Ugolino's four innocent children; in short, Dante
would again be participating in the sin that is being punished.
Finally, Dante meets Frate Alberigo in a state of physical numbness
and promises to remove the ice from Alberigo's eyes if the sinner
will identify himself--another promise which Dante never intends
to keep. In this way, Baldassaro argues that the icy realm of
Cocytus would be the so-called objective correlative to Dante's
frozen heart, allowing him to see his own potential for sin so
that he can be purified in Purgatory with humility.
Baraff, Barbara. "On the 'Unity' of Inferno III." In Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 115-121. [1990]
Taking issue with Natalino Sapegno's claim that the third canto
of the Inferno has serious structural flaws, Baraff argues
that "a tightly interwoven narrative is not the only device
available to an author to produce a harmonious effect" and
sides with Momigliano in insisting that the canto's unity derives
from its setting, tone, and the numerous Virgilian echos. "This
is one of the few episodes in the Inferno where Dante affords
the reader a sweeping panorama of the landscape," writes
Baraff, who observes further that the projection of psychological
mood onto physical landscape infuses the canto with an alternative
type of "background" logic.
Baranski, Zygmunt G. "The Constraints of Form: Towards a Provisional Definition of Petrarch's Triumphi." In Petrarch's "Triumphs"... pp. 63-83. [1990]
Makes passing references to Dante's De vulgari eloquentia
and Letter to Can Grande della Scala, as well as to the overall
structure of the Comedy in his attempts to illustrate the
unity among Petrarch's Trionfi and to understand Petrarch's
use of allegory and symbolism in the poems. One conclusion is
that, while Dante's Comedy is a truly Christian allegory
in terms of both form and symbolism, Petrarch's Trionfi
have a Christian message in an inherently pagan form and structure.
Baranski, Zygmunt G. "The Marvellous and the Comic: Toward a Reading of Inferno XVI." In Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 72-95. [1990]
Inferno XVI betrays a richly metaliterary character hitherto
unacknowledged in the tradition of the lectura Dantis.
It plays a key role in the structure of the Comedy, for
it is the first canto which so insistently demands to be read,
not as an autonomous unit, but as part of a broader ideological
and formal framework. With Inf. XVI, Dante was intentionally
forging a link between the Comedy and the multifaceted
and "marvelous" nature of Geryon, and through this link,
to the literary tradition as a whole. However, in order to stress
the originality and range of his own poem, the Poet needed a "marvelous"
being whose traditional lineaments were so vague that he could
redraw them almost entirely. He did this by amplifying Geryon
in such a way that, through his unique summative qualities, he
would also suggest the unique nature of Dante's own text.
Baranski, Zygmunt G. "Reflecting on Dante in America: 1949-1990." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 58-86. [1990]
Because of its status as both aesthetic artifact and hermeneutic investigation, the Divine Comedy has provoked considerable discussion during the past forty years. Regardless of which position one takes, both are certainly allowed and indeed invited by Dante, so that it seems likely he would not be displeased by the ways in which American criticism has fed on his work.
Barber, Joseph A. "A Statistical Analysis of the Fiore." Lectura Dantis, VI (Spring), 100-122. [1990]
Presents the results of a number of statistical analyses which
consider frequencies of common verbs/words/prepositions and distributions
of nouns and adjectives according to syllable length in Fiore,
Dante's Divine Comedy and Rime, and the lyrics of
the Duecento, Trecento, and Antonio Pucci. From these results
Barber argues that Dante is probably not the author of Fiore
and suggests directions for future research on the problem.
Barolini, Teodolinda. "For the Record: The Epistle to Cangrande and Various American Dantisti." In Lectura Dantis, VI (Spring), 140-143. [1990]
In this response to Ralph G. Hall and Madison U. Sowell's article
"Cursus in the Can Grande Epistle: A Forger Shows
His Hand?" (see Dante Studies CVIII, 133), Barolini
notes that the authors' extreme polarization of American from
European dantisti in the matter of the authenticity of
the Epistle to Cangrande would appear to reflect their lack of
understanding of this issue. They seem to have conflated the ideologies
and positions taken by both sides in such a way as to blur distinctions
rather than to clarify them. The confusion and lack of critical
consensus about the balance of importance between the literal
and the allegorical reading intended by the Poet may be due in
great measure to the excessive importance granted the question
of the Epistle and its paternity. Ultimately, Barolini believes
that the authenticity of the Epistle may be a red herring that
detours scholars from the more important issue of the Comedy's
narrative and representational strategies and its mode of signifying.
Barolini, Teodolinda. "Narrative and Style in Lower Hell." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 314-344. [1990]
Constrained by narrative limits such as having to create presence
so that he might make absence evident by means of contrast, Dante
makes Hell conform to his own laws rather than God's. Working
relentlessly to situate us within his own speculum, Dante
seeks to reorient us so that if we see things from within his
world, we will not realize how much he deviates from God's laws,
which are not representable with conventional narrative means.
Barolini, Teodolinda. "Q: Does Dante Hope for Vergil's Salvation? A: Why Do We Care? For the Very Reason We Should not Ask the Question (Response to Mowbray Allan [MLN, 104]." In MLN, CV, No. 1 (January), 138-144. [1990]
Responding to Allan's article (see Dante Studies, CVIII,
114), Barolini notes that the Divine Comedy, accepted by
readers as depicting an ontological reality with an extension
into the future, gives us no reason not to hope for Virgil's salvation.
It is, however, possible to debate whether Virgil's salvation
is theologically plausible. Nevertheless, since Dante makes us
care about Virgil, we can never really doubt whether Dante hopes
for Virgil's salvation.
Barolini, Teodolinda. "Second Response to Mowbray Allan." In MLN", CV, No. 1 (January), 147-149. [1990]
The fact that Dante creates a possible world in such an overdetermined
manner in no way collapses the distinction between the possible
and real worlds. It does, however, provide Dante ample opportunity
to blur distinctions so that we will collapse it for him. In the
real world, theologians do not make us hope for Virgil's salvation,
but in the possible world we can. (For Allan's first response,
see above.)
Barolini, Teodolinda. "Stile e narrativa nel basso inferno dantesco." In Lettere italiane, XLII, No. 2 (aprile-giugno), 173-207. [1990]
Italian version of "Narrative and Style in Lower Hell"
(see above).
Bernardo, Aldo S. "Sex and Salvation in the Middle Ages: From the Romance of the Rose to the Divine Comedy." In Italica, LXVII, No. 3 (Autumn), 305-318. [1990]
Both the Divine Comedy and the Romance of the Rose
pose, as a central moral dilemma, the ineluctable power of love.
In both works the Rose symbolizes the ultimate object of human
passion; in the former it represents the ultimate satisfaction
of an all-consuming spiritual passion; in the latter it represents
woman's body and the protagonist's furious need to possess it.
Bernardo sees an essential connection between the two works in
the fact that "both protagonists are in some ways lovers
seeking satisfaction of their love."
Bernardo, Aldo S. "Triumphal Poetry: Dante, Petrarch, and Boccaccio." In Petrarch's "Triumphs"..., pp. 33-45. [1990]
Examines the use of the Roman triumph in canto XXIX of Dante's
Purgatorio, Boccaccio's Amorosa Visione, and Petrarch's
Trionfi. Bernardo compares the three poets' use of the
triumph to illustrate the similarities and differences among them.
First of all, Petrarch and Boccaccio, following Dante's example,
write using terza rima and the poets experience the allegorical
triumphs while asleep or in a mystical vision. All three poets
have their beloved as the focal point of the triumphs, as well
as needing a guide who will explain the allegory to the poet.
However, Bernardo also shows how these triumphal poems illustrate
the differences in the three poets' perspectives: Dante's point
of view could be called divine or omniscient, seeing the human
through God's eyes; Boccaccio's and Petrarch's are of a human
dimension with the former's physical love leading to a more pure
love, and the latter's glory of virtuous deeds outlasting the
passage of time. Bernardo ends by demonstrating how Petrarch's
Trionfi lack the negative elements that Dante and Boccaccio's
triumphs have, explaining his greater influence on the thinkers
of the Renaissance.
Biow, Douglas George. "Narrative Self-Consciousness of the Marvelous in Virgil, Dante, Ariosto, and Tasso." In Dissertation Abstracts International, LI, No. 5 (November), 1629-A. [1990]
Doctoral Dissertation, The Johns Hopkins University. 269 p. (Concerns
primarily the episode of Polydorus.)
Bollettino, Vincenzo. "Giovanni Boccaccio: Life of Dante (Vita di Dante; Trattatello in Laude di Dante)." In Dissertation Abstracts International, L, No. 11 (May), 3611-A. [1990]
Doctoral Dissertation, Rutgers University, 1989. 241 p. (See above,
under Translations.)
Botterill, Steven. "Dante Studies and the Study of Dante." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 88-102. [1990]
One could hardly debate the fact that the history of Dante studies
is, in fact, the history of the journal Dante Studies,
yet the question remains: how did this come to be so? The article
first considers how this came to be so, and second, how the prestige
of Dante Studies has enabled it to function as an integral
part of Dante scholarship, shaping how (primarily) American scholars
regard the status of Dante's works.
Botterill, Steven. "Inferno XXIX: Capocchio and the Limits of Realism." In Italiana 1988... (q. v.), pp. 23-33. [1990]
Though most twentieth-century analysis has insisted on the realism
of this canto, the author argues on the basis of the figurative
language, intertextual references, and the depiction of Capocchio
that the "nature and function of realism in Inferno
XXIX ought to be reconsidered." Capocchio's aping of nature
in his alchemy is linked to Dante's mimesis of nature in his poetry.
In Inferno XI Dante refers to Aristotle's discussion of
mimesis in the Physics which Aquinas used to show that
imitation must be governed by moral means and ends. Capocchio,
who was "damned for the moral corruption of his art,"
recognizes Dante as a "spiritual kinsman" and thus serves
as a warning to Dante of the potential danger of mimesis.
Botterill, Steven. "Legato con amore in un volume: Uberto Limentani and the Cambridge Lecturae Dantis." In Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 29-35. [1990]
A student of the late Limentani, Botterill traces his teacher's
role in the development of Dante studies at Cambridge after the
Second World War. Although his major interest was not the Trecento,
Limentani's lifelong commitment to the study and teaching of Dante
was always aimed at reaching as wide an audience as possible.
For this and for his work for the Cambridge lecturae Dantis,
he well deserves to be called a Dantist.
Botterill, Steven. "Life after Beatrice: Bernard of Clairvaux in Paradiso XXXI." In Texas Studies in Literature and Language, XXXII, No. 1 (Spring), 120-136. [1990]
With the term "guide" reserved for Virgil and Beatrice,
Bernard's role in Paradiso is best summed up by the word
"sponsor." Neither his renown for eloquence nor his
place as advocate of the Virgin makes Bernard special in Dante's
eyes. Rather it is the combination of these attributes and his
representation of active contemplation that give him the responsibility,
indeed privilege, of preparing Dante for the ultimate deificatory
vision.
Briosi, Sandro. "Due voci per un dizionario di retorica." In Quaderni d'italianistica, XI, No. 2 (Autunno), 290-298. [1990]
In the first these two voci ("Metafora") we find
a short reference to Dante, concerning his particular, typically
medieval use of metaphor and allegory.
Brogan, Jacqueline Vaught. "It Must Be Re-Newed: Dante's Comedy and Stevens' Notes Toward a Supreme Fiction." In Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 122-132. [1990]
Reviews several of Dante's concerns, including the mutability
of language, faith, and history, and emphasizes Wallace Stevens'
revision of the Comedy.
Brown Herson, Ellen. "Oxymoron and Dante's Gates of Hell in Shelley's Prometheus Unbound." In Studies in Romanticism, XXIX, No. 3 (Fall), 371-393. [1990]
Oxymoron emerges as one of the principal rhetorical figures encountered
in Shelley's Prometheus Unbound and is often suggestive
of oxymoron as employed in the Divine Comedy.
Brownlee, Kevin. "Language and Desire in Paradiso XXVI." In Lectura Dantis, VI (Spring), 46-59. [1990]
In canto XXVI two of the Comedy's principal themes, love
and language, are treated in terms of Dante's authority as a theologian
and as a poet. By posing as a second Paul in the first part of
the canto, and as a second Adam in the latter half, Dante authorizes
himself as a Christian poet and legitimates his commitment to
a vernacular poetics. "By Paradiso 26 erotic desire
has become caritas and poetic language has become theology.
But neither eros nor poetry has been displaced, or even transcended:
rather, both are represented as 'fulfilled,' as 'redeemed,' within
the context of what must be seen as Dante's Incarnational
poetics."
Cachey, Theodore J., Jr. "Between Hermeneutics and Poetics: Modern American Translation of the Commedia." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 144-164. [1990]
The range of translations provoked by a given work stands as a
testament to the literary history of that text's reception by
other linguistic fields. Consequently, we expect that a work such
as the Divine Comedy might produce a variety of translations
arousing critical interest concerning the history and theory of
translation. To date, this has not occurred, although Cachey suggests
some areas for further consideration.
Carruthers, Mary J. The Book of Memory: A Study of Memory in Medieval Culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. xiv, 393 p. 30 Plates. [1990]
Contains some scattered references to Dante (Divine Comedy,
Vita Nuova) and one brief discussion of Paolo and Francesca's
reading of Lancelot (Inf. V) with regard to the key words
"memory," "desire," "reading," and
"punto."
Casagrande, Gino. "Esto Visibile Parlare: A Synaesthetic Approach to Purgatorio 10.55-63." In Lectura Dantis Newberryana... (q. v.), pp. 21-57. [1990]
Casagrande first describes Dante's use of synaesthesia in general
and then gives an extensive background, including an explanation
of the scholastic doctrine of the common sense (sensus communis).
Using the passage from the Purgatorio (X, 55-63), he demonstrates
the synaesthetic connection between the fragrance of the incense
and the laud of the choirs in terms of their semantic axis, which
he shows to be prayer.
Caserta, Ernesto G. "Croce's Essay on Dante." In Italian Culture, VIII, 121-136. [1990]
A retrospective appraisal of Croce's La poesia di Dante
in the context of nineteenth-century Dante studies and Croce's
theory of aesthetics. Croce's essay condemned "pedantic Dantists,
who had made Dante their god and worshipped him with mysterious
rituals." He worked to "demystify the Dante cult"
by removing the "parasitic vegetation" that had so surrounded
Dante "in order that the genuine and immortal voice of Dante
might be heard." Croce's aesthetics insisted on the autonomy
of art, the interaction between poetry and reader, and the poet's
limitations in understanding his own work. Thus, he saw nineteenth-century
philological, biographical, allegorical, political, moral, aesthetic,
and theological studies as only means to the end of enjoying and
explaining Dante's art. For Croce, political, theological, and
philosohical concerns undergo a lyrical or aesthetic synthesis,
thus creating an original work of art.
Cecchetti, Giovanni. "The Statius Episode: Observations on Dante's Conception of Poetry." In Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 96-114. [1990]
A well-balanced, orderly presentation of Purgatorio XXI
and XXII, which also considers such larger issues as the nature
and function of poetry. Concludes that the "great meaning
of the Statius episode" is its "exaltation of the redeeming
power of poetry, and a consecration of Dante the poet, who writes
the Commedia in order to save mankind." While acknowledging
that "Statius appears as a figura Christi," Cecchetti
argues that "the real figura Christi is poetry, which
uplifts and redeems. Dante is on the one hand Statius saved through
his 'vocale spirto,' and on the other, more importantly, Virgil,
called to save the world with a new Aeneid that is also
a new Bible. He is the personification of Statius and Virgil combined...and
at the same time the new redeemer armed with the divine power...of
poetry."
Cervigni, Dino S. "Dante and Modern American Criticism: An Introductory Essay." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 5-28. [1990]
Serves as an overview of the essays contained in this volume of
Annali dedicated to "Dante and Modern American Criticism,"
with appropriate critical commentary on each.
Cervigni, Dino S. "The Eunoè or the Recovery of the Lost Good." In Lectura Dantis Newberryana... (q. v.), pp. 59-80. [1990]
According to scholastic theology, the sacrament of Penance simultaneously
takes away sin and revives the soul's lost virtues and merits.
In Dante's Earthly Paradise this takes place in two poetically
distinct moments: the soul's immersion in Lethe deletes its sinfulness,
while drinking from Eunoè brings back to life the good
the soul had previously done and later lost on account of sin.
The author supports this thesis with extensive quotations from
the Bible, particularly Ezekiel, as well as from Thomas Aquinas
and several other church Fathers.
Chance, Jane. "Chaucer's Zephirus: Dante's Zefiro, St. Dominic, and the Idea of the General Prologue." In The Mythographic Art: Classical Fable and the Rise of the Vernacular in Early France and England, edited by Jane Chance (Gainesville: University of Florida Press), pp. 177-198. [1990]
Reviews Dante's treatment of Zefiro in canto XII of Paradiso,
which Chaucer used as a model. Argues that St. Dominic, whose
birth was caused in part by Zefiro's fructification of Castile,
is a type or Christian analogue of Zefiro in restoring and tending
Christ's garden or vineyard.
Chiappelli, Fredi. "Il colore della menzogna nelle scenografie dell'Inferno." In Lectura Dantis, VI (Spring), 3-27. [1990]
Treats the "coloration" of the landscapes of the Inferno.
Chiappelli notes how the color which best characterizes the atmosphere
of hell--the color purple-black (from the expression aere
perso in canto V)--reflects the complete hopelessness of the
damned. Other colors which the poet uses to portray various states
of mind are vermillion--the color of blood--and biacca
or white lead. Dante uses different colors to "tint"
the conversations of the damned in such a way as to underscore
the mendacity underlying their words.
Cioffi, Caron Ann. "The Sins of the Blind Father: The Statian Source for Dante's Presentation of Ugolino in Inferno 32 and 33." In Lectura Dantis Newberryana... (q. v.), pp. 81-93. [1990]
Cioffi compares and contrasts Inferno XXXII and XXXIII
with various episodes in Statius' Thebaid, suggesting that
"lower Dis, like Thebes, is the ultimate disutopia."
The article focuses on three important Statian scenes: Menalippus'
mutilation of Tydeus, the violence that surrounds Oedipus' relationship
with his sons, and the betrayal of Amphiaraus. These episodes
emphasize the ways in which individual acts of violence and betrayal
rend the larger fabric of society--a theme that is central to
the last few cantos in the Inferno.
Coiner, Nancy Lee. "The Figure in the Margins: Literary Autobiography in the Middle Ages." In Dissertation Abstracts International, L, No. 12 (June), 3944-A. [1990]
Doctoral Dissertation, Stanford University, 1989. 345 p. (For
Dante the author argues that "allegory's role in self-representation
stems from the way it combines figurality with temporal narrative
structures" and examines "how allegorical exegesis (frame
and commentary) and allegorical wordplay on the author's name
enable autobiographical discourse.")
Colilli, Paul. "Harold Bloom and the Post-theological Dante." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 132-143. [1990]
Dante, while virtually nowhere to be found in the work of Harold
Bloom, is nevertheless a pivotal figure in the critic's theoretical
methodology, perhaps even testifying implicity in favor of the
viability of his theoretical premises.
Comollo, Adriano. Il dissenso religioso in Dante. Firenze: Leo S. Olschki. 153 p. (Biblioteca dell'"Archivum Romanicum," 235.) [1990]
Discusses the various heterodox movements in Dante's day and analyzes
Dante's views on the Church and, in particular, those places in
the Divine Comedy where the poet appears to depart from
the official Church dogma. Contents: Premessa; Introduzione;
1. Profilo dell'eresia ai tempi di Dante (1250-1350); 2. Influenze
dirette: amici, maestri, educatori; 3. Accuse, condanne, anatemi
di autorità religiose e politiche contro Dante. La censura
e Dante; 4. Il "messaggio" religioso-profetico di Dante
nell'interpretazione della critica lungo i secoli; 5. Il topos
della corruzione della chiesa nella Commedia e negli autori
cattolici del tempo; 6. La storia della chiesa secondo Dante;
Conclusione; Bibliografia; Indice dei nomi.
Comollo, Adriano. "Religious Dissent in Dante." In Dissertation Abstracts International, L, No. 10 (April), 3245-A. [1990]
Doctoral Dissertation, University of Wisconsin, 1989. 301 p. (See
above.)
Cornish, Alison. "The Epistle of James in Inferno 26." In Traditio, XLV (1989-90), 367-379. [1990]
Cornish uses St. James' discourse on the evils of speech to explain
the incongruous juxtaposition of Ulysses with Guido da Montefeltro
in Inferno XXVI. While on first glance the "magnanimity
of Ulysses and the pusillanimity of Guido appear most opposed,"
Cornish argues that their respective acts of presumption rather
than of fraudulent counsel are the basis for the canto's contrapasso.
She proposes that Dante's addition of the image of the "fiery
tongue" to the "neoplatonic commonplace of steering
horses and ships" found in both works "constitutes an
invective against eloquence, against philosophical overreaching,
against intellectual presumption."
Cornish, Alison. "Planets and Angels in Paradiso XXIX: The First Moment." In Dante Studies, CVIII, 1-28. [1990]
Investigates the problems presented in the ambiguous astronomical
image with which Paradiso XXIX begins and links this astronomical
exordium with the initial moment in creation of the universe,
particularly the seemingly paradoxical moment in which the angels
were created and that in which some fell. Cornish concludes: "The
astronomical exordium can indeed be seen as a representation of
the first instant of creation, but of the angels rather than of
the planets. The balance of the first instant corresponds to the
momentary neither/nor in which the angels were created equal,
undecided, in imperfect grace, and in an ambiguous half-light.
Yet the twilight and dawn immediately distinguish themselves as
one entity rises into a spring morning, and the other, under an
autumnal sign, drops beneath the earth to night. The same simple
movement yields two opposite results. In addition, the celestial
zenith from which depend the two lights of heaven, as we are asked
to imagine them, can then correspond to the point "dove s'appunta
ogne ubi e ogne quando" on which Beatrice fixes
her gaze. The universe has thus been imbalanced ever since it
was released from the zenith of eternity and ubiquity--statim
post. Just as the evenings and mornings of the first lines
of Genesis are incomprehensible without the exaltation of angelic
knowledge as their literal meaning, the significance of the opening
image of Paradiso XXIX requires the same metaphysical link.
Dante's choice of the sun and the moon to evoke the temporal aporia
of the world's beginning reflects the correlation of time with
celestial movement that has persisted since antiquity. The immediate
admittance of evil into the pristine work of a perfect Creator
is represented by the various effects of those same celestial
bodies: twilight, morning, night."
Corti, Maria. "On the Metaphors of Sailing, Flight, and Tongues of Fire in the Episode of Ulysses (Inferno 26)." In Stanford Italian Review, IX, Nos. 1-2, 33-47. [1990]
Investigates the canto of Ulysses (Inf. XXVI) with regard
to three related metaphors and their respective semantic fields
and relationships with the earlier literary tradition from Augustine
and Boethius to Dante: 1) sailing, 2) flight, and 3) the tongues
of fire, all of which may be interpreted both allegorically and
metaphorically.
Croce, Benedetto. Benedetto Croce: Essays on Literature and Literary Criticism. Annotated and Translated from the Italian with an Introduction by M. E. Moss. Albany: State University of New York Press. xi, 244 p. [1990]
In addition to several references to Dante in the Introduction,
the volume contains translations of Croce's essays on Dante: "The
Character and Unity of Dante's Poetry" (69-74, 208) ["Carattere
e unità nella poesia di Dante," in La poesia di
Dante] and "Dante: The Concluding Canto of the Commedia"
(75-82, 209-210) ["Dante: L'ultimo canto della Commedia,"
in Poesia antica e moderna].
Dante's "Divine Comedy": Introductory Readings. I: "Inferno." Edited by Tibor Wlassics. Lectura Dantis VI: Supplement (Spring): Special Issue: Lectura Dantis Virginiana, I. [1990]
Contains individual readings of the thirty-four cantos of Inferno,
fourteen of which appeared in volumes 1-4 of Lectura Dantis.
Contents: Tibor Wlassics, Presentation (3-4); Ricardo J.
Quinones, I (5-16); Antonio C. Mastrobuono, II (17-27); Mario
Trovato, III (28-41); Amilcare A. Iannucci, IV (42-53); Thomas
Goddard Bergin, V (54-69); Denise Heilbronn, VI (70-81); Dennis
Looney, VII (82-92); Christopher Kleinhenz, VIII (93-109); Joseph
A. Barber, IX (110-123); Glauco Cambon, X (124-138); Pier Massimo
Forni, XI (139-148); Steven Botterill, XII (149-162); Aldo Scaglione,
XIII (163-172); Giuseppe C. Di Scipio, XIV (173-188); Peter Armour,
XV (189-208); Susan Noakes, XVI (209-221); Paolo Cherchi, XVII
(222-234); H. Wayne Storey, XVIII (235-246); Dante Della Terza,
XIX (247-261); Teodolinda Barolini, XX (262-274); Egidio Lunardi,
XXI (275-280); Joseph D. Falvo, XXII (281-296); Regina Psaki,
XXIII (297-306); George D. Economou, XXIV (307-318); Marianne
Shapiro, XXV (319-331); Ruggero Stefanini, XXVI (332-350); Lino
Pertile, XXVII (351-362); Mark Parker, XXVIII (363-372); Darby
Tench, XXIX (373-387); Donna Yowell, XXX (388-399); Giovanni Cecchetti,
XXXI (400-411); William M. Wilson, XXXII (412-418); Robert J.
Di Pietro, XXXIII (419-427); Dino S. Cervigni, XXXIV (428-438).
De Bonfils Templer, Margherita. "Le due ineffabilitadi del Convivio." In Dante Studies, CVIII, 67-78. [1990]
Treats Dante's twofold notion of ineffability--"inintelligibilità"
and "impotenza espressiva" (Convivio III, iii)--and
its dependency on William of Conches' Glosae super Timaeum
Platonis. In addition, the author notes: "Ciò
che veramente s'impone attraverso una considerazione delle due
ineffabilitadi dantesche del Convivio è l'assenza
di una connotazione mistica delle stesse, e la preponderanza,
nell'intero trattato dantesco, del problema gnoseologico come
problema degli intelligibili e della intelligibilità."
De Bonfils Templer, Margherita. "'La prima materia de li elementi'." In Studi danteschi, LVIII (1990 for 1986), 275-291. [1990]
Through several textual comparisons it is established a close
relation between William of Conches' Glosae and the examined
passage from the Convivio. It is therefore very probable
that Dante follows William's exegesis even though he doesn't mention
the monk's name.
De Fazio, Marina R. "Dante Studies: A Decade of American Dissertations (1980-1989)." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 166-178. [1990]
A useful, partially annotated bibliography of American doctoral
dissertations, which focus on Dante and his works either primarily
or secondarily.
De Fazio, Marina R. "The Scribe and the Inventor: The Poet in Inferno." In Lectura Dantis, VI (Spring), 60-68. [1990]
Examines the authorial "intrusions" in Inferno.
An analysis of the "author" in the Comedy, both
pilgrim and artistic creation, in relation to his work brings
out "an ambivalence between two conflicting notions of his
role as poet": the scribe who "humbly and faithfully"
reports his experience; the inventor "whose aim is to write
the poem which will rank him high among the poets of all times."
There are three types of authorial intrusions: 1) in which the
"poet refers to himself in terms of his experience as a pilgrim";
2) in which the "poet seems to acquire a historical consistency
which relates to the political events of his times"; and
3) in which the "narrator shows his identity as the poet
who is writing the work we are reading". Connecting Ulysses'
"folle volo" with the narrator's own "folle venuta,"
the author argues that throughout the poem there is a struggle
between poetic "humility and superiority." Reviewing
verbs of telling and narrating in the episodes of Filippo Argenti,
Geryon and Pier della Vigna and their role in the analogy between
the levels of journey and writing, she concludes that "the
borders between truth and lie, between reality and poetic fiction,
are not always easily distinguishable."
Doob, Penelope Reed. The Idea of the Labyrinth from Classical Antiquity through the Middle Ages. Ithaca, New York, and London: Cornell University Press. xviii, 355 p. [1990]
In a section devoted to Dante ("Dante's Divine Comedy:
The Labyrinthine Landscape; The Labyrinthine Journey; The Myth
Transformed and Reenacted"), the author demonstrates the
pattern and path of the labyrinth in the Comedy throughout
which Dante "uses and corrects Virgil and Boethius."
There are three models of the labyrinth in the Comedy:
"the inextricable prison-labyrinth of hell, the probative
unicursal labyrinth of purgatory, and the circling spheres and
souls of paradise." Argues that the art of heaven perfects
the imperfections of the other realms. Dante's journey through
the maze demonstrates that "perfect understanding is impossible,
but...circuitous process is epistemologically essential."
In his manipulation and redefinition of the labyrinth, Dante,
utilizing the Cretan myth, "plays virtually every role in
the legend at some point."
Durling, Robert M., and Ronald L. Martinez. Time and the Crystal: Studies in Dante's "Rime Petrose." Berkeley-Los Angeles-Oxford: University of California Press. xii, 486 p. (A Centennial Book.) [1990]
Contains an extended commentary on the rime petrose and
on their relationship to other of Dante's works (especially Vita
Nuova, Convivio, De Vulgari Eloquentia, and
Divine Comedy). The authors offer many insights on the
special character of Dante's "microcosmic poetics" which
are introduced in the petrose and which will have a decided
shaping effect on the conception and composition of the Divine
Comedy. Investigation of the earlier literary, philosophical,
and scientific traditions from which Dante drew his ideas. For
the latter body of works the authors treat subjects from a wide
range of sources--astronomy, astrology, zoology, mineralogy, human
biology--and suggest how Dante intricately joins them in his poetry
to capture the struggle of the lover with these material forces
and to depict his relationship with the universe (microcosm-macrocosm).
According to the authors, the notion of constant change in the
sublunary sphere is central to the petrose, which deal
with the cyclical change of seasons and astral influence, as well
as with those forces that, like the woman's obduracy, work against
this sort of movement--the coldness of winter, the self-destructive
violent negativity of the lover. An Introduction provides the
pertinent scientific and philosophical background, and the first
chapter analyzes the way Dante's early work, the Vita Nuova,
stems from and reflects those traditions. The next four chapters
(2-5) discuss the four rime petrose, one per chapter, and
the final chapter investigates the several ways in which these
poems influence the Divine Comedy in theme and structure.
The appendices deal with, among other things, number symbolism
in the sestina metrical form and the variety of precious
stones mentioned in the Paradiso, as well as texts and
original English translations of the petrose, the first
canzone of the Vita Nuova ("Donne ch'avete
intelletto d'amore"), and the incomplete second book of De
Vulgari Eloquentia. Contents: Preface; Introduction;
1. Early Experiments: Vita Nuova 19; 2. The Solstice and
the Human Body: "Io son venuto al punto de la rota";
3. The Sun and the Heliotrope: "Al poco giorno e al gran
cerchio d'ombra"; 4. The Poem as Crystal: "Amor, tu
vedi ben che questa donna"; 5. Breaking the Ice: "Così
nel mio parlar voglio esser aspro"; 6. The Rime petrose
and the Commedia; Appendix 1. "Nascentis militie dies";
Appendix 2. The Numerology of the Sestina; Appendix 3. Precious
Stones in the Paradiso; Appendix 4. Texts and Translations:
The Rime petrose; Vita Nuova 19; De vulgari eloquentia,
Book 2; Notes; Bibliography; Index.
Durocher, Richard J. "Dante, Milton, and the Art of Visible Speech." In Comparative Literature Studies, XXVII, No. 3, 157-171. [1990]
Dante's influence on Milton's treatment of the "archetypal
sinner's allegorical history" and the "pilgrim's fitful
visionary return to God," largely unappreciated to date,
is clear in a comparison between Purgatorio and Books XI-XII
of Paradise Lost. The author argues that, "while distancing
himself from Dante's theology, Milton applauds Dante's art,"
especially his narrative devices. The series of artworks in cantos
X through XVII are reflected in Adam's vision of the future in
Book XI. Milton also parallels "Dante's strategy of describing
his participation in various sins," and the "cycles
of vision-response-correction." The Paradise available to
humans is "a paradise within." Though both Dante the
pilgrim and Adam have ascended in visions of God, only Dante "continues
to rise to apprehend Paradise restored."
Erasmi, Gabriele. "Petrarch's Trionfi: The Poetics of Humanism." In Petrarch's "Triumphs"..., pp. 161-174. [1990]
The catalyst of Petrarch's Trionfi lies in the poet's renewal
of the notion of the triumphal procession which gives the work
not only form and unity but also allows deployment of the catalogue.
A narrative created by a visual compendium of biblical, classical
and modern exempla demonstrates meditation of ancient thought
under the stimulus of modern preoccupations defining a certain
poetics of humanism. References contrasting particular characteristics
and episodes of the Divine Comedy are made under closer
examination of the Triumphus amoris.
Evans, Cynthia. "Can an 'Old, Dead Classic' Be Revived?" In Studies in Medieval and Renaissance Teaching, n.s. I, No. 2 (Fall), 21-28. [1990]
Explains some approaches to classroom study of the Inferno,
including creating illuminated manuscripts and physical models
of the landscape. The use of "dialectical journals"
in which students summarize some aspect of the poem on one page
and give personal reactions on the facing page generates critical
thinking.
Fleming, John V. Classical Imitation and Interpretation in Chaucer's Troilus. Lincoln and London: University of Nebraska Press. xviii, 276 p. [1990]
Contains a number of references to Dante.
Forni, Pier Massimo. "Boccaccio's Answer to Dante." In Thought: A Review of Culture and Idea, LXV, 256 (March), 71-82. [1990]
Contrasts aspects of the artistic personalities of Dante and Boccaccio,
using the Comedy and the Decameron as primary references.
Dante's tendency to judge and pigeonhole stands in contrast to
Boccaccio's more conciliatory style, his "concessive nonchalance."
Gilewicz, Magdalena. "The Strategies of Allegory in Dante, Spenser, and Conrad." In Dissertation Abstracts International, LI, No. 6 (December), 2010-A. [1990]
Doctoral Dissertation, State University of New York at Stony Brook,
1989. 267 p.
Grace, John Patrick. "Dante's Polemic against Greed and His Portrait of Saint Francis." In Dissertation Abstracts International, L, No. 12 (June), 3972-A. [1990]
Doctoral Dissertation, University of North Carolina, 1988. 176
p.
Grlic, Olga. "Four Virgilian Heroes in Canto 1 of the Inferno." In Stanford Italian Review, IX, Nos. 1-2, 49-52. [1990]
Discusses briefly Dante's moral and political reasons for the
grouping of the four figures of Camilla, Eurylus, Nisus, and Turnus
in Inferno I (vv. 106-108). "For Dante, these Virgilian
characters represent the victims of greed signified by the lupa:
he sees them united in their desire for spoils, which blinded
them to the real causes and issues of the war and ultimately caused
their downfall."
Gunzberg, Lynn M. "'Nuotando altrimenti che nel Serchio:' Dante as Vademecum for Primo Levi." In Reason and Light: Essays on Primo Levi, edited by Susan R. Tarrow (Ithaca, New York: Center for International Studies, Cornell University), pp. 82-98. (Western Societies Program, Occasional Paper No. 25.) [1990]
Examines Levi's use of Dante's Inferno (particularly cantos
XXI-XXII) for his Survival in Auschwitz. "Levi found
that Dante had provided him with a way to make sense of the experience,
with a precise, detailed, medieval but universal and rational
conceptualization of the irrational. The Dantean model, evoked
by the several direct citations and allusions throughout Survival
in Auschwitz, helped Levi relate his experience in terms which
were familiar to Italian readers."
Hall, Ralph G., and Madison U. Sowell. "On Dante and "Cursus": A Brief Response to "For the Record." In Lectura Dantis, VI (Spring), 143-144. [1990]
Written in reaction to Teodolinda Barolini's response ("For
the Record..." for which see above) to their earlier article
("Cursus in the Can Grande Epistle..." for which
see Dante Studies, CVIII, 133). Reasserting their belief
in the inauthenticity of the Epistle to Can Grande, Hall and Sowell
underline the fact that Barolini's response was not based on the
evidence they had offered, clarify the American/European split
on the issue, and argue that, though the Comedy is best
approached through the text itself, the "privileging of the
Pseudo-Dantean Epistle" will continue to distract us from
doing so.
Harrison, Robert Pogue. "Phenomenology of the Vita nuova." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 180-184. [1990]
Dante's Vita nuova is the literary testimony of his probing
the meaning of the life and death of Beatrice as giving rise to
a certain transcendence inexplicable because of the finite nature
of time. Hence, the Vita nuova provides a phenomenological
testament unlike what we might reasonably expect to find embedded
in the timelessness of the Divine Comedy.
Harrison, Robert Pogue. "Vision and Revision: The Provisionary Essence of the Vita Nuova." In Texas Studies in Literature and Language, XXXII, No. 1 (Spring), 6-17. [1990]
Whether the ending of the Vita Nuova constitutes a "rifacimento,"
one which recognizes the episodes of the "donna gentile"
as the libello's original final chapters, remains an enigma
by way of solely philological interpretations. Instead, the work's
revisionary narrative throughout and remarkable use of the subjunctive
at the end create an ending which extends into provisionary time,
providing both a closure for the libello and an opening
for the ultimate vision in the Comedy. (This essay constitutes
the last chapter of author's book The Body of Beatrice,
see Dante Studies, CVII, 139-140.)
Hart, Thomas Elwood. "The Cristo-Rhymes, the Greek Cross, and Cruciform Geometry in Dante's Commedia: 'giunture di quadranti in tondo'." In Zeitschrift für romanische Philologie, CVI, Nos. 1-2, 106-134. [1990]
Intrigued by the fact that the Cristo-rhymes in cantos
XIV and XIX of the Paradiso appear in exactly the same
lines (104, 106, and 108), Hart undertakes a series of geometric
calculations to discover whether Dante had used Archimedes' ratios
(used to calculate the circumference of a circle) to predetermine
the precise location of all four of the Comedy's Cristo-rhymes.
The Cristo-rhymes occur at amazingly proportional intervals,
suggesting the quadrants of a circumscribed Greek cross (two equal
diameters at right angles).
Hatcher, Elizabeth R. "Dante, psychoanalysis, and the (erotic) meaning of meaning." In Bulletin of the Menninger Clinic, LIV, 353-367. [1990]
Using a history-of-ideas approach, Hatcher examines
the roots of the polysemous interpretation of dream-symbolism
on the part of modern psychoanalysts; this she traces to the medieval
practice of the polysemous interpretatation of reality, illustrated
through Dante's poetics which operate on a literal, allegorical,
moral, and anagogical level. She also sketches the autobiographical
elements which operate within the Comedy.
Havely, N. R. "Brunetto and Palinurus." In Dante Studies, CVIII, 29-38. [1990]
Studies the complex interplay between the Palinurus episode in
Virgil's Aeneid and the Pilgrim's encounter with Brunetto
Latini (Inferno XV), and in particular the significance
of the displacement of mentors: respectively of Palinurus by the
Sibyl and of Brunetto by Virgil.
Hollander, Robert. "The 'Canto of the Word' (Inferno 2)." In Lectura Dantis Newberryana... (q. v.), pp. 95-119. [1990]
Examines the intensely discursive nature of the canto by explicating
the seven "speeches" found therein. Central to the discussion
is the relationship between the power of the word and poetic authority,
and Hollander examines the process by which the authority of Virgil
is diminished, while that of Dante is heightened.
Hollander, Robert. "Purgatorio II: The New Song and the Old. In Lectura Dantis, VI (Spring), 28-45. [1990]
Argues that no matter how beautiful the Comedy "was
for its maker and is for its readers, Dante composed it with the
intent to censure a merely aesthetic appreciation of the text."
Having reviewed Virgil and Dante's inadequacies as poets and guides,
the author decides that the allegory in Purgatorio II is
closer to that described in Convivio II.i than that in
the Epistle to Cangrande. Dante's insistence on the "experiential
veracity" of his voyage shows that Dante's "poetics
forced him to pretend" that his poem enters "the continuum
of history rather than remaining suspended in the excogitations
of timeless allegoresis." In any case, "Dante continues
to act, as does Casella, in ways that recall his former rather
than his hoped-for future life." They, like the reader, are
lost in the beauty of the old song and forget the new song.
Howard, Lloyd. "Linguistic Patterns and Internal Structure in Five canti of the Inferno." In Quaderni d'italianistica, XI, No. 1 (Primavera), 85-90. [1990]
In Inferno VI Ciacco notes that other political worthies
are found in Hell, thus preparing Dante the Pilgrim and the reader
for subsequent cantos in which these individuals are presented
as politicians. While these worthies have certain similarities,
the episodes in which they are presented are joined through formulas
of linguistic repetition which make these connections clear.
Iannucci, Amilcare A. "Casella's Song and Tuning of the Soul." In Thought: A Review of Culture and Idea, LXV, No. 256 (March), 27-46. [1990]
The Pilgrim's passage from the total disorder of Hell to Purgatory
is meant to be a reclamation and reaffirmation of the order that
governs the universe. In Purgatorio II this is symbolized
by Dante's recovery of music and the harmony that it represents.
Iannucci gives a fuller musical interpretation of this canto,
one that takes into account the three categories encompassed by
the medieval concept of music: cosmic, human, and sonorous.
Italiana 1988, Selected Papers from the Proceedings of the Fifth Annual Conference of the American Association of Teachers of Italian. (November 18-20, 1988). Monterey, CA. Edited by Albert N. Mancini, Paolo A. Giordano, and Anthony J. Tamburri. Rosary College Italian Studies, 4 (River Forest, IL). [1990]
Contains articles on Dante by Steven Botterill and Christopher
Kleinhenz. Each essay is listed separately in this bibliography
under the individual author's name.
Kallendorf, Craig. "Nachleben." In Vergilius, XXXVI, 82-98. [1990]
The article is part of a special report on "Vergilian Scholarship
in the Nineties: A Panel Sponsored by the Vergilian Society of
America" and contains a section devoted to Virgil in Dante
with abundant references to current scholarship on the topic.
Kay, Richard. "Dante's Acrostic Allegations: Inferno XII." In Res Publica Litterarum, XIII, 123-135. [1990]
Complements two earlier articles concerning "Dante's acrostic
allegations" in Inferno XI (see Dante Studies,
CVI, 138 and 155). Connects various sequences of the first syllables
of tercets to other works, including Dante's own, which contain
discussions of the material at hand. Examines verses in relation
to their sources, including Aristotle, Ovid, Aquinas, Orosius,
and St. Paul.
Kim, Myungbok. "The Poetics of Praeludere: Dante and Wordsworth." In Dissertation Abstracts International, L, No. 11 (May), 3579-A. [1990]
Doctoral Dissertation, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign,
1989. 177 p. (A comparative/contrastive study of the Vita Nuova
and Wordsworth's The Prelude as preparatory to their projected
works: the Divine Comedy and the Recluse. Examines
the notion of the "productivity of poetry-writing: what gets
its started and what keeps it going.")
King, Roma A., Jr. The Pattern in the Web: The Mythical Poetry of Charles Williams. Kent, Ohio, and London: Kent State University Press. x, 189 p. [1990]
Contains numerous references to Dante.
Kirkpatrick, Robin. "Dante's Beatrice and the Politics of Singularity." In Texas Studies in Literature and Language, XXXII, No. 1 (Spring), 101-119. [1990]
This essay explores the notion of individuality and Dante's experimentation
with selfhood as they are manifested in his writings, especially
through the figure of Beatrice. An understanding of the poet's
singularity rests primarily upon an examination of portions of
the Vita Nuova and the Comedy, with particular emphasis
on the last cantos of Purgatorio.
Klein, Ilona. "Dante and the Franciscan Movement." In Thought: A Review of Culture and Idea, LXV, No. 256 (March), 7-16. [1990]
Intended for a general audience, this essay briefly sketches the
life and influence of St. Francis and his Order on the philosophy
of Dante. Gives special emphasis to the necessity of a return
to apostolic poverty in order to achieve a genuine reform of the
Church.
Kleiner, John. "The Eclipses in the Paradiso." In Stanford Italian Review, IX, Nos. 1-2, 5-32. [1990]
Examines Dante's use of shadows and eclipses in the Paradiso,
particularly in cantos II, X, and XXIX where they "mark each
of the critical thresholds crossed by the pilgrim. These shadows...compromise
paradise's pure light to produce a legible display; each liminal
shadow is both an imperfection or impurity and a sign." Because
the eclipses have a "disruptive effect," they may be
seen as "threats to the Paradiso's intelligibility,
...genuine obstacles to interpretive process." However, Kleiner
argues that the eclipses play a crucial role in the interpretive
structure in the poem.
Kleiner, John. "Finding the Center: Revelation and Reticence in the Vita Nuova." In Texas Studies in Literature and Language, XXXII, No. 1 (Spring), 85-100. [1990]
The centered pattern of the Vita Nuova is imperfect as
the work strains toward two centers: one which is marked at chapter
XXIII (where the poet's revelatory vision of Beatrice's death
occurs) and at chapter XXVIII (where the real event is quietly
recorded). The formal transposition of poems and their "divisioni"
and Dante's use of the introductory words "appresso"
and "poi" attest to this opposing configuration. The
instability of the Vita Nuova's center discloses a crisis
and, at the same time, reaffirms its central importance.
Kleinhenz, Christopher. "American Dante Bibliography for 1989." In Dante Studies, CVIII, 113-172. [1990]
With brief analyses.
Kleinhenz, Christopher. "Biblical Citation in Dante's Divine Comedy." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 346-359. [1990]
Dante's biblical allusions call forth biblical texts in a variety
of manners, creating a "poetics of citation." Since
Dante integrates biblical passages in a way that often forces
reconsideration of the citation's usage, he simultaneously calls
forth the written and visual traditions attached to the specific
text, thus moving the reader beyond the textual limits established
by the Divine Comedy itself.
Kleinhenz, Christopher. "Dante and the Tradition of Visual Arts in the Middle Ages." In Thought: A Review of Culture and Idea, LXV, No. 256 (March), 17-26. [1990]
The visual character of much of Dante's imagery is well recognized.
This essay, which in its oral presentation was illustrated with
slides, surveys briefly some of the most important of the visual
images found in the Comedy. Considers the iconographical
elements which Dante has assimilated from the earlier artistic
tradition and provides examples which illustrate the Comedy's
impact on the subsequent artistic tradition up to the present
day.
Kleinhenz, Christopher. "Dante as Reader and Critic of Courtly Literature." In Courtly Literature: Culture and Context: Selected Papers from the 5th Triennial Congress of the International Courtly Literature Society, Dalfsen, The Netherlands, 9-16 August, 1986), edited by Keith Busby and Erik Kooper (Amsterdam and Philadelphia, Penn.: John Benjamins), pp. 379-393. [1990]
Throughout his works, Dante develops a new attitude toward cortesia,
one springing from spiritual origins and deriving its impetus
and characterstics from the right ordering of the soul in accordance
with God's will and divine plan. As the poet develops this new
attitude toward the court and courtliness, he shows himself to
be not only a careful reader, but also an astute critic of courtly
literature. In the Divine Comedy, the secular tradition
comes to its inevitable end and is replaced by its spiritual counterpart.
Kleinhenz, Christopher. "The Poetics of Citation: Dante's Divina Commedia and the Bible." In Italiana 1988... (q. v.), pp. 1-21. [1990]
Investigates Dante's technique in the Comedy of evoking
the Bible through the use of an exact or modified version of the
Latin text or an Italian translation or paraphrase of the Vulgate.
While using some scriptural citations simply for their immediate
evocative value, Dante employs many others whose function in the
text may be fully understood only through a careful consideration
of the larger context established by the Bible and the biblical
commentary tradition. Analyzes, in particular, the episode of
Farinata in Inferno X to order to demonstrate how meaning
is generated by a remarkable conjunction of individual words,
complete phrases, and images, through which Dante draws attention
to the specific biblical text and its larger referential context
of the Passion, Crucifixion, and Resurrection. These considerations
are set in motion by Dante's insistence on the biblical citation--"la
tua loquela ti fa manifesto" (X, 25)--which sets in motion
the entire series of intertextual connections.
Knoespel, Kenneth J. "When the Sky Was Paper: Dante's Cranes and Reading as Migration." In Lectura Dantis Newberryana... (q. v.), pp. 121-146. [1990]
Drawing on sources as varied as Homer and Derrida, the author
considers the topos of bird formations as a representation of
words and argues that Dante's use of the figure "quite literally
works to instruct readers how, exerting, vigilance and diligence,
they should negotiate their way through the narration." The
image of "ordered groups of cranes," for the Roman poets
a military metaphor and for the church fathers a model for monastic
obedience, becomes for Dante a "model for politicians and
poets." It is not only a pattern of words but a "migratory
procession...of evolving illumination" for both the reader
and Dante the pilgrim. The last part of the essay explores Dante's
hermeneutical method, showing that the Comedy "is
not simply a field in which to identify topoi, but a philosophical
narrative that challenges readers constantly to negotiate meaning."
Koterski, Joseph W., S. J. "Messianic Expectations in the Fourteenth Century." In Thought: A Review of Culture and Idea, LXV, No. 256 (March), 47-58. [1990]
Christopher Dawson has emphasized that reform movements in the
Church helped to stimulate the creation of a Christian culture.
Dante's political vision and his attacks on a corrupt Church are
situated within the context of papal reforms going back to Hildebrand.
His own hope for a political solution and his expectation of an
apocalyptic transformation are contrasted with the vision presented
in Piers Plowman.
Kuehn, Heinz R. "A Descent into Hell." In Sewanee Review, XCVIII, No. 2 (Spring), 324-329. [1990]
Review of Jeffrey Burton Russell, The Prince of Darkness: Radical
Evil and the Power of Good (Ithaca, New York: Cornell University
Press, 1988), which treats in part the "diabology of Dante."
La Favia, Louis M. "Thomas Aquinas and Siger of Brabant in Dante's Paradiso." In Lectura Dantis Newberryana... (q. v.), pp. 147-172. [1990]
After providing an extensive biographical and historical background
to Siger of Brabant and the controversies surrounding him, La
Favia attempts to account for Siger's presence in the Heaven of
the Sun. Rejecting the solutions of Madonnet, Van Steenberghen,
Gilson and Nardi, he attempts to ascertain what Dante could have
known about Siger and Averroes and how he himself regarded them.
Siger is not exclusively a symbol of pure philosophy, but of philosophy
buttressed in its limitations by theology. The juxtaposition of
Siger and Aquinas exemplifies perfectly the underlying theme of
the canto: concordia discors.
Lectura Dantis Newberryana, Volume II. Lectures presented at the Newberry Library, Chicago, Illinois, 1985-1987. Edited by Paolo Cherchi and Antonio C. Mastrobuono. Evanston, Illinois: Northwestern University Press. viii, 186 p. [1990]
Contains essays by Lawrence Baldassaro, Gino Casagrande, Dino
S. Cervigni, Caron Ann Cioffi, Robert Hollander, Kenneth J. Knoespel,
Louis M. La Favia, and Michelangelo Picone. Each essay is listed
separately in this bibliography under the individual author's
name.
Lindheim, Nancy. "Body, Soul, and Immortality: Some Readings in Dante's Commedia." In MLN, CV, No. 1 (January), 1-32. [1990]
Argues that images of the body are for Dante a nexus of hope and
faith in an eternal material reality. Dante's belief in a bodily
resurrection and his deep and ardent respect for human relationships
motivate his anti-Averroism. Whenever the body becomes a
subject of discourse--in the canto of the suicides,
for example, or Manfred's interest in his body's reburial--it
serves as a reminder of how human gestures, often motivated by
a momentary impulse, resound with eternal value. "The resurrection
of the body...is for Dante a guarantee of the permanent importance
of the individual person's life in this world."
Lollini, Massimo. "Ineffabilità, retorica e amicizia. Percorsi di una teoria della testimonianza in Dante e Agostino." In NEMLA Italian Studies, XIII-XIV (1989-90), 5-21. [1990]
Discusses the three topoi of inexpressibility, affected
modesty and the exordium (and their interrelationships), as well
as the theme of friendship, in the classical and medieval tradition
and as they appear in the works of Dante, and particularly in
the final canto of Paradiso with the beatific vision. "Possiamo
concludere allora che l'ineffabilità della gloria divina,
non rappresenta l'autentica conclusione del viaggio dantesco,
ma piuttosto lo strumento retorico e poetico attraverso cui Dante
ci ricorda che noi stiamo leggendo un'opera poetica che cerca
di descrivere qualcosa che non può essere esaurito dalle
parole umane, se non nei termini di una incessante interpretazione
e di una continua ricerca di senso."
Looney, Dennis. "Purgation and Emendation of a Simile: Purgatorio VI and VII." In Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 133-141. [1990]
Suggests that the introductory simile in Purgatorio VI
that likens the pilgrim to the game-winner is rewritten in the
following canto where Virgil would be seen as the loser. Looney
argues that this sort of rewriting/reworking or transformation
is central to Dante's poetics of the Purgatorio, as is
the analogy between the human soul, which gradually moves upward
toward perfection, and the poet's progess toward holiness, which
is officially recognized at the conclusion of canto XXVII. This
reconciliation of "matera" and "arte" has
a complement in these cantos in the discussion of prayer and its
power to amend defects.
Lund-Mead, Carolynn Ruth. "The Pilgrimage of the Son to the Father in the Works of Virgil, Dante and Milton." In Dissertation Abstracts International, L, No. 9 (March), 2889-A. [1990]
Doctoral Dissertation, University of Toronto, 1989.
Martinez, Ronald (Joint author). See Robert M. Durling,
Time and the Crystal...
Mastrobuono, Antonio C. Dante's Journey of Sanctification. Washington, D.C.: Regnery Gateway. xiii, 279 p. [1990]
Mastrobuono argues for a correction of Charles Singleton's view
expressed in Journey to Beatrice that, in his words, "Dante's
journey through Inferno and Purgatory under the guidance of Virgil
is a preparation for santifying grace, which Dante supposedly
receives at the advent of Beatrice on the mountaintop of Purgatory.
Mastrobuono's premise is that "Singleton's thesis...is based
on an erroneous interpretation of St. Thomas, and that Dante's
journey under Virgil's guidance through Inferno and Purgatory
is an effect of (not a preparation for) sanctifying grace, which
Dante has already received before entering the world beyond."
Chapter I is devoted to the exposition of this point. In Chapter
II Mastrobuono provides further documentation in support of his
view (expressed in his book, Essays on Dante's Philosophy of
History, see Dante Studies, XCVIII, 168) that "the
first day in Purgatory is not Easter Sunday as most critics believe.
It is, instead, simply a day in Purgatory corresponding to the
Vigil Night of Holy Saturday in Jerusalem." Chapter III reproduces
an earlier essay on the interpretation of Beatrice's prophecy
concerning the "cinquecento diece e cinque" (see Dante
Studies, CVII, 150). In the Appendix Mastrobuono presents
the extensive second part of his two-part review of the volume
by John Freccero, Dante: The Poetics of Conversion, concentrating
on his "interpretations concerning individual parts of the
Comedy" (for the first part of this review, see the
item below). Contents: Acknowledgments; Preface; I. Sanctifying
Grace: Justification and Merit; II. This is the day the Lord has
made; III. The Powerful Enigma: A Mortification of the Intellect;
Appendix: Review Article: A Book Twenty-Five Years in the Making.
Mastrobuono, Antonio C. "Review Article: A Book Twenty-Five Years in the Making." Italian Culture, VIII, 13-37. [1990]
Review-article of the volume by John Freccero, Dante: The Poetics
of Conversion (See Dante Studies, CV, 148). In this
first part of a two-part review (for the second part, see the
Appendix in Mastrobuono's Dante's Journey of Sanctification,
above) the author treats Freccero's "view of the poem as
a whole."
McGregor, James H. "Is Beatrice Boccaccio's Most Successful Fiction?" In Texas Studies in Literature and Language", XXXII, No. 1 (Spring), 137-151. [1990]
In his Trattatello in laude di Dante Boccaccio "reveals"
Beatrice's historical identity in order to manipulate her role
in Dante's spiritual and literary development. In order to establish
his own vision of Dante and his work--one more in keeping with
emerging Renaissance ideals--Boccaccio diminishes the place of
Beatrice, especially as she is represented in the Vita Nuova.
Montano, Rocco. "Il commento alla Divina Commedia di Charles S. Singleton." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 104-114. [1990]
Argues that Singleton's work fails, in many ways, to provide the
basic ideas and information that one should find in a commentary
two thousand pages long. Singleton does not generally address
the major esthetical and philosophical problems involved in the
text, but, on those occasions when he does, this is done with
confusion and misunderstanding.
Narducci, Rinamaria. "I poeti in volgare del De vulgari eloquentia." In Dissertation Abstracts International, LI, No. 5 (November), 1632-1633-A. [1990]
Doctoral Dissertation, University of Pennsylvania. 194 p.
Noakes, Susan. "Hermeneutics, Politics, and Civic Ideology in the Vita Nuova: Thoughts Preliminary to an Interpretation." In Texas Studies in Literature and Language, XXXII, No. 1 (Spring), 40-59. [1990]
Dante's new vernacular style seeks to find the middle ground of
the sociopolitically disparate environment of his time by espousing
an idealized hermeneutic practice. By building a linguistic framework
upon the interplay between stable and shifting meanings Dante
creates a lay literature which serves to attract a new readership.
External, internal and theoretical approaches suggest that the
Vita Nuova should be, on a certain level, integrated into
the corpus of Dante's political works.
Nolan, Edward Peter. Now through a Glass Darkly: Specular Images of Being and Knowing from Virgil to Chaucer. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. 316 p. [1990]
Chapter 7 ("The Descending Dove: Dante's Francesca as the
Anti-Beatrice") deals specifically with Dante's representation
of figures as texts and mirrors of recte legendi, right
reading. By tracking discourses and authoritative sources quoted
and alluded to which represent thoughts and feelings in Dante's
and Chaucer's characters, we gain insight which facilitates our
assessment of these characters as literary constructs and as implied
human beings suffering into truth.
Parel, A. J. "Machiavelli's Use of Civic Humanist Rhetoric." In Rhetorica, VIII, No. 2 (Spring), 119-136. [1990]
Machiavelli's discussion of Trajan in his Protestatio di iustitia
relies on Dante's version of the legend in Purgatorio X,
73-93, though Dante emphasizes faith rather than justice.
Pelikan, Jaroslav. Eternal Feminines: Three Theological Allegories in Dante's "Paradiso." New Brunswick, New Jersey: Rutgers University Press. xiii, 144 p. (Mason Welch Gross Lecture Series.) [1990]
Discusses the three "eternal feminines"--Beatrice, the
Church, and the Virgin Mary (which are "historical, and yet
allegorical, and therefore theological") and their interrelationships
and position in the ideological structure of the poem--and investigates
the larger question of the theology of the interaction between
this world and the next in Christian thought and in the Divine
Comedy. Pelikan is thus able to analyze the Paradiso
as a whole and to address, as well, questions concerning monasticism,
papal politics, the medieval ideas on justice, power and wisdom,
and Dante's relationship to Augustine and Boethius. Contents:
Preface; Abbreviations; Prologue: Tre Donne; The Otherworldly
World of the Paradiso; Lady Philosophy as Nutrix
and Magistra; Beatrice as Donna Mia; The Church
as Bella Sposa; Mary as Nostra Regina; Epilogue:
Wisdom as Sophia and Sapienza; Bibliography.
Pertile, Lino. "La punta del disio: storia di una metafora dantesca." In Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 3-28. [1990]
Through semantic and intertextual analyses Pertile discusses 1)
the way in which Dante follows the mystic Christian tradition
adopting erotic terminology to express the desire to be with God
and 2) how Dante goes beyond this tradition by using this terminology
also for the desire of kwowledge. In this identity of the search
for God and the search for knowledge there is further evidence
of the common inspiration of both the Convivio and the
Divine Comedy.
Petrarch's "Triumphs": Allegory and Spectacle. Edited by Konrad Eisenbichler and Amilcare A. Iannucci. Toronto: Dovehouse Editions. xv, 420 p. (University of Toronto Italian Series, 4.) [1990]
The volume is based on a symposium held at the University of Toronto,
May 1-3, 1987. Contains essays which deal in part with Dante by
Zygmunt G. Baranski, Aldo S. Bernardo, Gabriele Erasmi, and Massimo
Verdicchio. Each essay is listed separately in this bibliography
under the individual author's name.
Picone, Michelangelo. "Poetic Discourse and Courtly Love: An Intertextual Analysis of Inferno 5." In Lectura Dantis Newberryana... (q. v.), pp. 173-186. [1990]
Picone defends the view that the Comedy--and Inferno
V in particular--represents Dante's rewriting and correcting of
the Arthurian romances and their language of desire. The poet's
intention is disclosed by his use of the word menare. In
contrast to the ill-directed language of desire found in the romantic
tradition and epitomized by Francesca, Dante's language of desire
is correctly oriented toward its divine source, caritas.
Potter, Joy Hambuechen. "Beatrice, Dead or Alive: Love in the Vita Nuova." In Texas Studies in Literature and Language, XXXII, No. 1 (Spring), 60-84. [1990]
Identifies numerous textual elements of the Vita Nuova
in terms of a power struggle. Dante's attempt to free himself
from the sensual power of Beatrice centers basically on linguistic
maneuvers which seek to defeminize her character and on various
distancing devices deployed by the work as a "Book of Memory."
In this way Dante creates an "Otherness" for Beatrice,
one which no longer shares in sexuality and hence prepares her
for her role in the Divine Comedy, while also asserting
the poet's place in the male domain of literature.
Potter, Joy Hambuechen. "Glauco Cambon." In Lectura Dantis, VI (Spring), 123-139. [1990]
A sensitive review and appreciation of the late comparatist's
many contributions to Dante criticism (e.g., Dante's Craft
[see Dante Studies, LXXXVIII, 179]).
Preston, Janet L. "Dantean Imagery in Blue Velvet." Literature/Film Quarterly, XVIII, No. 3, 167-172. [1990]
Notes the thematic and symbolic correlations between the Divine
Comedy and the film "Blue Velvet." Each work represents
an "initiation journey" through realms of depravity
in pursuit of self-knowledge. The article notes the use of color
and imagery to evoke a subterranean world with specific references
to Dante's Inferno; in particular, the author notes a connection
between Dorothy Vallen's apartment and Dante's seventh circle
of Hell. Whereas Dante is ultimately saved by his love for Beatrice,
the salvation of the film's protagonist is provisional, marked
by ambiguity and temporality. In pointing out the thread of paradox
that runs throughout the film, Preston argues for "Blue Velvet"
as a revision of the Comedy in which "Beatrice"
is tainted and "Dante's" future is uncertain.
Quinn, William A. "Dante in the Trenches: Doctrinaire Irony at a State University." In Thought: A Review of Culture and Idea, LXV, 256 (March), 59-70. [1990]
The author relates his experience in teaching the Inferno
at the University of Arkansas to students whom he categorizes
as being neither heathens, heretics, or hedonists. Notes that
in the context of a secular university an ironic approach to the
work has served him well.
Quinones, Ricardo J. "Dante and Modernism." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 30-36. [1990]
Among other things, the Modernist movement in criticism has given
rise to a new appreciation of personality in fiction. More specifically,
Modernism has imbued critics with the realization that the poet
is not a singular voice, but rather a voice among many within
his or her own text. Never is this more prevalent than in the
Purgatorio, where Dante the poet becomes less a Triton
among the waves and more a person with shared human qualities.
Quinones, Ricardo J. "Lectura Dantis: Purgatorio VIII." In Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 47-59. [1990]
A thorough-going, orderly reading and appreciation of Purgatorio
VIII, which considers it for its particular intrinsic merits and
in its larger contextual relationship with other cantos.
Robey, David. "Dante and Modern American Criticism: Post-structuralism." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 116-131. [1990]
While it is debatable whether assimilation of criticism by post-structuralism
is possible, it is evident that we sometimes find such a merger.
This merger is clearly present in some recent Dante criticism
which, for all its post-structuralist shortcomings, nonetheless
embraces many post-structuralist tendencies in efforts to explicate
further its critical premises.
Ross, Charles S. "Dante and Dominion: Castles from Epic to T. S. Eliot." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 38-56. [1990]
From ancient epics to modern fiction, the castle has frequently
served as a topos, one where a knight usually does battle
and, upon vanquishing his enemy, is called upon to uphold the
custom of the castle. But in the Middle Ages, custom tends to
indicate a negative valence, a tendency upheld by Dante in the
Inferno and later reversed in the Paradiso.
Saly, John. "A Rereading of Inferno IX." In Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 36-46. [1990]
Discusses Inferno IX as a microcosm of the anagogic level
of allegory that permeates the entire Comedy. The pattern
of "arrest and restart" in place since canto I of the
Inferno is intensified in canto IX in order to emphasize
the overall movement, integral to a reading of the allegorical
progress of the Pilgrim, as one marked by moments of paralyzing
self-doubt and subsequent self-knowledge.
Sanguineti, Edoardo. "Infernal Acoustics: Sacred Song and Earthly Song." In Lectura Dantis, VI (Spring), 69-79. [1990]
Drawing on terminology set forth by Boito and Shafer, the author
argues that "the soundscape of Hell...cannot be reduced to
mere musical emptiness" (excluding Nimrod's horn and Mastro
Adamo's belly); rather, there is a "meditated and meaningful
plenitude of 'antimusic'...[of] disharmonic harshness and acoustic
unpleasantness." In the Inferno listening, which usually
precedes seeing, is often directed toward distortions and perversions
of the sacred, most noteworthy the parody of Venantius Fortunatus'
hymn in canto XXXIV. This parody throughout the Inferno
sets up the dichotomy in Purgatorio II between the sacred
song and the earthly song--In Exitu Israel de Aegypto and
Amor che nella mente mi ragione. This dichotomy dramatizes
the beginning of the movement "from the esthetic to the ethical
life" and to a transcendence of both.
Schiller, Kay E. "Dante and Kantorowicz: Medieval History as Art and Autobiography." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 396-411. [1990]
While some may view Ernst Kantorowicz's choice of opening The
King's Two Bodies with Shakespeare and closing it with Dante
as arbitrary, it seems more likely a deliberate choice on his
part.
Scott, John A. "Dante and Philosophy." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 258-277. [1990]
The view that the Divine Comedy represents Dante's rejection
of his earlier "flirtation" with philosophy seems to
be shared by many American Dante scholars. Yet, it is difficult
to accept such a claim, especially given such evidence as Cato's
cautioning Dante that music distracts our souls, and Dante the
Poet's cautioning us, in Purgatorio, that it is music--and
not true philosophy--which can be an obstacle.
Shapiro, Marianne. "Ecphrasis in Virgil and Dante." In Comparative Literature, XLII, No. 2 (Spring), 97-115. [1990]
Just as Virgil drew upon Homer's depiction of Achilles' shield,
Dante draws upon the tradition of ecphrasis as presented by Virgil.
His introduction to Purgatory signals the poet's succession to
that realm, an arrival engaging both the poet and the pilgrim.
By doing so, Dante documents the progress of the writer as artist
and encapsulates the epistemologically ambivalent situation of
poetry as a didactic source and a repository of information.
Shoaf, R. A. "'Dante in ynglyssh': The Prologue to the Legend of Good Women and Inf. 13 (Chaucer and Pier della Vigna)." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 384-394. [1990]
American Chaucerian scholarship has been concerned with how Chaucer
might be situated with respect to Dante, whether as the "medieval
English Virgil" or as the "anti-Dante." None of
these views seems wholly appropriate, as Chaucer's Prologue
to the Legend of Good Women indicates in its establishment
of a link to Inferno XIII. "There is more of Dante
in Chaucer than most readers are currently willing to admit. In
fact, there is in Chaucer at least this much of Dante, that if
Chaucer is not Dante, Dante taught Chaucer not, and how not, to
be Dante."
Shoaf, R. A. "Purgatorio and Pearl: Transgression and Transcendence." In Texas Studies in Literature and Language, XXXII, No. 1 (Spring), 152-168. [1990]
Literary evidence points to the Pearl poet's knowledge
of the Comedy. This is especially true in the configuration
of the stream that separates: dreamer and maiden in Pearl;
pilgrim and Matelda in Purgatorio. The notion of transgression
and the image of the ford in Pearl are modeled on Dante,
who, in turn, found his source in Scripture.
Sicari, Stephen. "History and Vision in Pound and Dante: A Purgatorial Poetics." In Paideuma, XIX, Nos. 1-2 (Spring/Fall), 9-35. [1990]
Examines how Pound's reading of Dante influenced his conception
of Imagism, particularly in regard to his reading of the Paradiso.
Beginning with Pound's critical works and moving into The Cantos,
Sicari traces Pound's interpretation of vision in the Comedy
as a cornerstone of his own poetics of transcendence through the
"Image."
Simoncini, Daniele. "Moduli interpretativi danteschi (Convivio 2.5.14)." In Quaderni d'italianistica, XI, No. 2 (Autunno), 265-268. [1990]
Dante's adherence to Thomism is often only formal. While St. Thomas
condemns the allegorical interpretation of pagan poets, Dante
still considers Virgil as a pagan prophet, because of his Fourth
Eclogue. Moreover, in the examined passage of the Convivio
Dante interprets Virgil's verses allegorically.
Sodi, Risa B. A Dante of Our Time: Primo Levi and Auschwitz. New York-Bern-Frankfurt am Main-Paris: Peter Lang. 112 p. (American University Studies. Series II: Romance Languages and Literature, Vol. 134.) [1990]
Traces the influence of Dante's Inferno on Primo Levi,
and particularly on the twentieth-century Italian author's Holocaust
narrative, Se questo è un uomo (1947) and his last
book of essays I sommersi e i salvati (1986). Among the
many links between Dante and Levi, Sodi explores the nature and
definition of justice, the importance and "weight of memory
on a person's soul," and the conception of a sort of neutral
zone "for Levi, la zona grigia, for Dante, ghe realm
of the neutral sinners--where categories of victims and oppressors,
sinners and saints blur ever so slightly but decisively."
Contents: Introduction; I. Al di qua del bene e del
male: Justice in Dante's Inferno and in Primo Levi's
First and Last Books; II. Neither in bono nor in malo:
The Grey Zone and the Neutral Sinners; III. Obliviscence and Reminiscence:
Memory and the Memory of Offense; Conclusion; Notes; Bibliography;
Index.
Sowell, Madison U. "Brunetto's Tesoro in Dante's Inferno." In Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 60-71. [1990]
Reevaluates an old problem with some fresh insights, gained through
the analysis of the specific textual relationship of the Tesoretto
with the first thirty verses of Inferno I.
Sowell, Madison U. "Dante in English: Recent Translations and Commentaries." In Thought: A Review of Culture and Idea, LXV, 256 (March), 83-92. [1990]
Discusses representative passages from a number of English translations
of the Comedy, beginning with that of John Ciardi. Although
expressing a preference for Mark Musa's translation, Sowell explains
his decision to use a bilingual edition for teaching the Comedy
to beginners. His own practice is to use the translations of Allen
Mandelbaum, Charles Singleton, and John Sinclair respectively
for each of the three canticles.
Sowell, Madison U. (Joint author). See Ralph G.
Hall, "On Dante and "Cursus"...
Spearing, A. C. "Troilus and Criseyde: The Illusion of Allusion." In Exemplaria, II, No. 1 (Spring), 263-277. [1990]
Allusion as a rhetorical device can be divided into two main categories:
strong and weak. Strong suggests that readers need to recognize
the context and exact circumstances of the allusion's referent
in order to respond accurately to the text at hand. Weak suggests
a more general knowledge of the allusion's referent, one in which
readers need only recognize the source and a few general facts
surrounding it. Chaucer primarily utilizes references to Dante
as weak allusions, asking modern audiences to be aware of how
much or, in this instance, how little knowledge of Dante's text
would have been readily available to Chaucer's audience.
Storey, Harry Wayne. "Lo 'stoscio' montiano-dantesco (Inf. XVII, 118-123)." in Studi danteschi, LVIII (1990 for 1986), 385-389. [1990]
With reference to the examples provided in Monte Andrea's poetry,
Storey discusses Dante's use of stoscio/scroscio
(Inf. XVII, 118-123) to describe the descent on Geryon's
back to the eighth circle and to provide a sort of acoustical
preparation for the Malebolge.
Took, John. "Dante and the Confessions of Augustine." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 360-382. [1990]
Like his Christian predecessors, Dante was an existentialist.
However, unlike them, and like Augustine, he pursues his inquiry
"from within." His works represent the point of view
of one not merely contemplating an idea, but struggling to come
to terms with it, just as we find Augustine struggling to come
to terms with the events of his life in the Confessions.
Trovato, Mario. "Dante's Poetics of Good: From Phenomenology to Integral Realism." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 232-256. [1990]
Bontade, or goodness, in Dante's work has received little
serious attention. Constituting the substratum for many of Dante's
works, goodness can best by explicated by first examining its
definition in the Convivio, second by defining the genealogical
tree of "good," and third by noting how good functions
in the Vita nuova, the Convivio, the De vulgari
eloquentia, and the Divine Comedy.
Trovato, Mario. "Dante's Stand against "l'errore de l'umana bontade": Bonum, Nobility and Rational Soul in the Fourth Treatise of the Convivio." In Dante Studies, CVIII, 79-96. [1990]
Argues that "in the fourth treatise [Dante] is attempting
to correct erroneous philosophical opinions regarding the nature
of the intellectual soul" believing "that Dante is addressing
and refuting such cultural centers as the University of Bologna,
whose masters were teaching and writing texts inspired by Averroistic
thought." According to Trovato, Dante drew many of his notions
from Albertus Magnus (De Natura boni, De bono, De
anima, and De natura et origine animae) and, particularly
that "the most noble form in nature is the intellectual soul
which is personal, and, like any form individualized into matter,
is a synonym for good." He continues: "By equating the
concepts of 'goodness,' 'nobility,' and 'human soul,' Dante's
treatise turns out to be substantially different from those in
which nobility was considered only as honest behavior (probitas
morum) or as a rational way of living." The article attempts
to provide answers to the following questions: "What is not
nobility" What constitutes "umana bontade"? Are
all men noble to the same degree? If not, what makes them differ
in nobility? How does nobility manifest itself? What is the role
of virtue in the framework of nobility?"
Valesio, Paolo. "La vena ermetica della Commedia." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 278-299. [1990]
A typical characteristic of hermeticism is the dealing with phantasmatic
beings, and we can find several of them described in the Comedy,
like the "shadows" of Hell and Purgatory (midway between
the spiritual and the material) or like frate Alberigo, who is
in Hell while his body is still alive on the Earth. It is thus
possible to find in the Comedy both a strict adherence
to the official tenets of metaphysics and also a condescension
for a phantasmatic theology of hermetic and popular provenience,
and the latter topic has still to be investigated in depth.
Verdicchio, Massimo. "Croce Reader of Dante." In Dante Studies, CVIII, 97-112. [1990]
Verdicchio notes that "Croce's reading of the Divina Commedia
has to be evaluated within the parameters set by him in the Estetica
of 1902 and in terms of the distinction of symbol and allegory
which he makes there between the artistic and the non-artistic"
and intends not only to "redress a 'wrong' reading of Croce
but to reassess the substance of a critical reading of Dante"
so that Croce's contribution to Dante studies may be clarified
and better understood. Verdicchio concludes that this "contribution...goes
beyond the assertion that the Commedia should be read as
poetry and not according to arbitrary historical and cultural
factors, that is, according to an allegory of reading that attributes
it meanings not its own. Croce's contribution is to have identified
the poetry of the Commedia with allegory and to have opened
the way for an investigation of its poetic nature in the mode
of poetic allegory."
Verdicchio, Massimo. "The Rhetoric of Enumeration in Petrarch's Trionfi." In Petrarch's "Triumphs"..., pp. 135-146. [1990]
Analyzes Petrarch's rhetorical use of enumeration in the Trionfi
and contrasts it to Dante's generally synechdochal use of catalogues
in the Divine Comedy.
Wallace, David. "Chaucer's Body Politic: Social and Narrative Self-Regulation." In Exemplaria, II, No. 1 (Spring), 221-240. [1990]
Argues that an "interchange of political and literary metaphors
seems essential to social and literary self-regulation";
in the Comedy "the text envisions itself as a journey
through a series of political systems," and at the end "all
such systems are figured as leaves of a single volume scattered
through the universe." Political and literary life are indistinguishable
for Dante. The author uses as an illustration Dante's meeting
with Guido da Montefeltro in Inferno XXVII, arguing that
the devil-logician who drags Guido off mirrors Boniface's promise,
exposing its fallacy: i.e., the devil has placed repentance in
rhetorical and historical sequence before will, just as Boniface
has placed absolution before penance. Thus, history, at least
for this devil, "can be restricted to the analysis of linguistic
terms." Guido is damned by the deficiencies of the language
he has "learned within religious institutions."
Wallace, David, ed. Beatrice Dolce Memoria, 1290-1990: Essays on the "Vita Nuova" and the Beatrice-Dante Relationship. Special issue of Texas Studies in Literature and Language, XXXII, No. 1 (Spring). [1990]
Contains essays by John Ahern, Steven Botterill, Robert Pogue
Harrison, Robin Kirkpatrick, John Kleiner, James H. McGregor,
Susan Noakes, Joy Hambuechen Potter, and R. A. Shoaf. Each essay
is listed separately in this bibliography under the individual
author's name.
Watts, Barbara Jane. "Studies in Sandro Botticelli's Drawings for Dante's Inferno." In Dissertation Abstracts International, LI, No. 2 (August), 326-A. [1990]
Doctoral Dissertation, University of Virginia, 1989. 318 p.
Wetherbee, Winthrop. "Romance and Epic in Chaucer's Knight's Tale." In Exemplaria, II, No. 1 (Spring), 303-328. [1990]
Examines the "tentative spirituality" of Dante's Statius
whose Thebaid, via Boccaccio's Teseida, Chaucer
continues in the Knight's Tale. Chaucer, like Boccaccio,
dissents from Dante's "anti-historical...appropriation of
classical poetry to Christian ends." In the Thebaid
"the medieval poets discovered a dual perspective on epic
experience, a strong sense of historical inevitability and political
necessity balanced by an obsession with beauty of what history
destroys and a faltering sense of its spiritual value." In
his depiction of Statius, Dante emphasizes his tendency to identify
with his female characters in "isolated moments of sympathy
and intuitive vision." Statius' most important contribution
is his account of the "formation of the human embryo and
the creation and afterlife of the soul," the most striking
feature of which is its "total omission of strictly human
experience." Though Statius' own shade is "formed by
very human feelings...we are given no earthly context for these
feelings." Thus, "for the purpose of Statius' discourse,
the soul has no history." Statius is limited in that his
instincts, like those of his female characters, are "reduced
to the vessel of a higher inspiration which gives them a transcendent
significance but does not redeem their human component."
Wlassics, Tibor. "Crux and Context in Dante's Comedy." In Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 300-313. [1990]
Regardless of how the audience of the Divine Comedy might
view the question of how the text should be interpreted, it seems
clear Dante calls for readmitting the Author to the status of
Privileged Reader.
Zupan, Patricia. "The New Dantean Alba: A Note on Paradiso X, 139-148." In Lectura Dantis, VI (Spring), 92-99. [1990]
Discusses the image of the clock, bride and bridegroom at the
end of Paradiso X as the product of Dante's blending together
erotic and religious themes from the Provençal albas:
Falquet de Romans' "Vers Dieus," Cerverí de Girona's
"Aixi con cel," and Giraut de Bornelh's "Reis Glorios."
Dante. The Banquet. Translated with an Introduction and Notes by Christopher Ryan. Saratoga, California: ANMA Libri, 1989. (See Dante Studies, CVIII, 114.) Reviewed by:
Theodore J. Cachey, Jr., in Annali d'Italianistica, VIII,
442-445.
Armour, Peter. The Door of Purgatory. A Study of Multiple Symbolism in Dante's "Purgatorio." Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1983. Reviewed by:
Luca Rossi, in La Fusta, VIII, No. 1 (Spring-Fall), 148-150.
Bloom, Harold. Ruin the Sacred Truths: Poetry and Belief from the Bible to the Present. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1989. (See Dante Studies, CVIII, 119.) Reviewed by:
Steven Helmling, in Kenyon Review, XII, No. 3 (Summer), 154-168;
Marcus Wilson, in Philosophy and Literature, XIV, No. 2
(October), 396-401.
Brunetto Latini. "Libro del tesoro". Versión castellana de "li livres dou Tresor." Edición y estudio de Spurgeon Baldwin. Madison, Wisconsin: Hispanic Seminary of Medieval Studies, 1989. Reviewed by:
Curt J. Wittlin, in La Corónica, XVIII, No. 2 (Spring),
107-109.
Cassell, Anthony K. Dante's Fearful Art of Justice. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1984. (See Dante Studies, CIII, 144.) Reviewed by:
Christopher Kleinhenz, in Italian Culture, VIII, 194-197;
Giuseppe Tardiola, in Rassegna della letteratura italiana,
XCIV, ser. VIII, No. 3 (settembre-dicembre), 170-172.
Chiappo, Leopoldo. Dante y la Psicología del Infierno. Lima, Perú: Atlas S. A., 1983. Reviewed by:
Mary Emily Becker, in Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 144-146.
Cipolla, Gaetano. Labyrinth: Studies on an Archetype. New York: Legas, 1987. (See Dante Studies, CVI, 128.) Reviewed by:
Penelope Reed Doob, in Italica, LXVII, No. 2 (Summer),
229-231.
Corsi, Sergio. Il "modus digressivus" nella "Divina Commedia." Potomac, Maryland: Scripta Humanistica, 1987. (See Dante Studies, CVI, 129.) Reviewed by:
Marianne Shapiro, in Italica, LVII, No. 2 (Summer), 231-234.
Dante among the Moderns. Edited by Stuart Y. McDougal. Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press, 1985. (See Dante Studies, CIV, 168.) Reviewed by:
James H. McGregor, in Yearbook of Comparative and General Literature,
XXXVI (1990 for 1987), 183-184.
Dante e la bibbia. Atti del Convegno Internazionale promosso da "Biblia." Firenze, 26-27-28 settembre 1986. Edited by Giovanni Barblan. Firenze: Leo S. Olschki, 1988. (See Dante Studies CVII, 131-133.) Reviewed by:
Roberto Gigliucci, in Rassegna della letteratura italiana,
XCIV, Nos. 1-2 (gennaio-agosto), 246-247.
Dante e le forme dell'allegoresi. Edited by Michelangelo Picone. Ravenna: Longo, 1987. (See Dante Studies, CVI, 130.) Reviewed by:
David P. Bénéteau, in Quaderni d'italianistica,
XI, No. 1 (Primavera), 146-147.
Dante Today. Edited by Amilcare A. Iannucci. Special issue of Quaderni d'Italianistica, X, Nos. 1-2 (Spring-Fall). Reviewed by:
M[ario] M[arti], in Giornale storico della letteratura italiana,
CLXVII, fasc. 540, 613-614.
Del Greco Lobner, Corinna. James Joyce's Italian Connection: The Poetics of the Word. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 1989. (See Dante Studies, CVIII, 127.) Reviewed by:
Mary T. Reynolds, in James Joyce Quarterly, XXVII, No.
3 (Spring), 665-668.
De Rachewiltz, Siegfried. De Sirenibus: An Inquiry into Sirens from Homer to Shakespeare. New York and London: Garland Publishing, 1987. (See Dante Studies, CVI, 132.) Reviewed by:
Anne Lake Prescott, in Envoi, II, No. 1 (Spring), 57-60.
Eco, Umberto. The Aesthetics of St. Thomas Aquinas, tr. by Hugo Breden. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1988. Reviewed by:
William Wilson, in Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 154-156.
Edwards, Robert R. The Dream of Chaucer: Representation and Reflection in the Early Narratives. Durham, North Carolina, and London: Duke University Press, 1989. (See Dante Studies, CVIII, 128.) Reviewed by:
Carol F. Heffernan, in Studies in the Age of Chaucer, XII, 277-278;
Robert M. Jordan, in Journal of English and Germanic Philology,
LXXXIX, No. 3 (July), 399-401.
L'espositione di Bernardino Daniello da Lucca sopra la Comedia di Dante. Edited by Robert Hollander and Jeffrey Schnapp, with Kevin Brownlee and Nancy Vickers. Hanover, New Hampshire, and London: University Press of New England, 1989. (See Dante Studies, CVIII, 129.) Reviewed by:
Mario Marti, in Giornale storico della letteratura italiana, CLXVII, fasc. 538, 285-288;
Aldo Vallone, in Annali d'Italianistica, VIII, 454-455.
Freccero, John. Dante: La poetica della conversione. Translated by Corrado Calenda. Bologna: Il Mulino, 1989. 358 p. Reviewed by:
Mauro Cursietti, in Rassegna della letteratura italiana, XCIV, ser. VIII, No. 3 (settembre-dicembre), 152-155;
Anna Longoni, in Strumenti critici, n.s. V, fasc. 2 (maggio),
280-286.
Giovannetti, Luciana. Dante in America: Bibliografia 1965-1980. Ravenna: Longo, 1987. (See Dante Studies, CVI, 134.) Reviewed by:
Christopher Kleinhenz, in Italica, LVII, No. 2 (Summer),
240-241.
Guinizelli, Guido. The Poetry of Guido Guinizelli. Edited and Translated by Robert Edwards. New York and London: Garland Publishing, 1987. (See Dante Studies, CVI, 135.) Reviewed by:
Vincent Moleta, in Italica, LXVII, No. 2 (Summer), 247-250.
Guzzardo, John G. Dante: Numerological Studies. New York: Peter Lang, 1987. (See Dante Studies, CVI, 135.) Reviewed by:
Victoria Kirkham, in Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 146-148;
Ilona Klein, in Italian Culture, VIII, 189-190;
Massimo Seriacopi, in Rassegna della letteratura italiana, XCIV, ser. VIII, No. 3 (settembre-dicembre), 158;
Marcellina Troncarelli, in Rassegna della letteratura italiana,
XCIV, ser. VIII, Nos. 1-2 (gennaio-agosto), 249.
Harrison, Robert Pogue. The Body of Beatrice. Baltimore, Maryland, and London: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1988. (See Dante Studies, CVII, 139-140.) Reviewed by:
Jo Ann Cavallo, in Italian Culture, VIII, 187-189;
Cristina Della Coletta, in Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 152-154;
Maria Rosa Menocal, in Romanic Review, LXXXI, No. 2 (March), 275-277;
Thomas C. Stillinger, in Italica, LXVII, No. 3 (Autumn),
403-406.
Hollander, Robert. Boccaccio's Last Fiction: "Il Corbaccio." Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1988. (See Dante Studies, CVII, 141.) Reviewed by:
Anthony K. Cassell, in Forum Italicum, XXIV, No. 2 (Fall), 289-292;
Dina Consolini, in Envoi, II, No. 1 (Spring), 91-94;
Tommaso Giartosio, in Rassegna della letteratura italiana,
XCIV, ser. VIII, No. 3 (settembre-dicembre), 208-209.
Holloway, Julia Bolton. Brunetto Latini: An Analytical Bibliography. London: Grant and Cutler, 1986. Reviewed by:
Baudouin Van Den Abeele, in Les lettres romanes, XLIV,
No. 4, 391-392.
Holloway, Julia Bolton. The Pilgrim and the Book: A
Study of Dante, Langland and Chaucer. New York-Bern-Frankfurt
am Main-Paris: Peter Lang, 1987. (See Dante Studies, CVI,
137.) Reviewed by: James Simpson, in Medium Aevum, LIX,
No. 1, 144.
Hyde, Thomas. The Poetic Theology of Love. Cupid in Renaissance Literature. Newark: University of Delaware Press; London and Toronto: Associated University Presses, 1986. (See Dante Studies, CV, 151.) Reviewed by:
S. K. Heninger, Jr., in Comparative Literature, XLII, No.
4 (Fall), 367-368.
L'idea deforme: Interpretazioni esoteriche di Dante. Edited by Maria Pia Pozzato. Introduzione di Umberto Eco. Postfazione di Alberto Asor Rosa. Milano: Bompiani, 1989. Reviewed by:
Francesco Guardiani, in Quaderni d'italianistica, XI, No.
1 (Primavera), 163.
Kelly, Henry Ansgar. Tragedy and Comedy from Dante to Pseudo-Dante. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989. (See Dante Studies, CVIII, 137.) Reviewed by:
Mario Marti, in Giornale storico della letteratura italiana,
CLXVII, fasc. 538, 303.
Kleinhenz, Christopher. The Early Italian Sonnet: The First Century (1220-1321). Lecce: Milella, 1986. (See Dante Studies, CV, 152.) Reviewed by:
Louis Chalon, in Le Moyen Age, XCVI, No. 2, 370-371;
Francesco Guardiani, in Quaderni d'italianistica, XI, No.
2 (Autunno), 314-316.
Lectura Dantis, I, No. 1 (Fall, 1987). Reviewed by:
Steven Botterill, in Romance Philology, XLIII, No. 3 (February),
491-492.
Lectura Dantis, IV (Spring, 1989). Reviewed by:
[unsigned], in Giornale storico della letteratura italiana,
CLXVII, fasc. 538, 303.
Lectura Dantis Newberryana, I. Lectures presented at the Newberry Library, Chicago, Ilinois, 1983-1985. Edited by Paolo Cherchi and Antonio C. Mastrobuono. Evanston, Illinois: Northwestern University Press, 1988. (See Dante Studies, CVII, 147-148.) Reviewed by:
Lawrence Baldassaro, in Envoi, II, No. 1 (Spring), 54-57.
Lynch, Kathryn L. The High Medieval Dream Vision: Poetry, Philosophy, and Literary Form. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1988. (See Dante Studies, CVII, 148.) Reviewed by:
Stefania D'Ottavi, in Medium Aevum, LIX, No. 2, 299-302;
John V. Fleming, in Envoi, II, No. 1 (Spring), 118-121;
Constance B. Hieatt, in Journal of English and Germanic Philology, LXXXIX, No. 2 (April), 212-213;
Harry F. Williams, in Romance Quarterly, XXXVII, 3 (August),
354-355.
Macdonald, Ronald R. The Burial-Places of Memory: Epic Underworlds in Vergil, Dante, and Milton. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1987. (See Dante Studies, CVI, 139.) Reviewed by:
K. W. Gransden, in Modern Language Review, LXXXV, No. 1
(January), 131-132.
Mastrobuono, Antonio C. Dante's Journey of Sanctification. Washington, D.C.: Regnery Gateway. (See above, under Studies.) Reviewed by:
David Goldfarb, in Italian Journal, IV, No. 6, 64-65.
Mazzotta, Giuseppe. The World at Play in Boccaccio's "Decameron." Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1986. (See Dante Studies, CV, 154-155.) Reviewed by:
H. Wayne Storey, in Speculum, LXV, No. 1 (January), 194-196.
McDannell, Colleen, and Bernhard Lang. Heaven: A History. New Haven, Conn., and London: Yale University Press, 1988. (See Dante Studies, CVII, 151.) Reviewed by:
William Luther White, in Christianity and Literature, XXXIX,
No. 2 (Winter), 200-201.
Medieval Literary Theory and Criticism c. 1100-c.1375: The Commentary Tradition. Edited by A. J. Minnis and A. B. Scott, with the assistance of David Wallace. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1988. Reviewed by:
Deborah Parker, in Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 148-150.
Menocal, Maria Rosa. The Arabic Role in Medieval Literary History: A Forgotten Heritage. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1987. (See Dante Studies, CVI, 141.) Reviewed by:
Dwayne E. Carpenter, in Romance Quarterly, XXXVII, No.
2 (May), 217-218.
Montano, Rocco. Dante's Thought and Poetry. Chicago, Illinois: Gateway, 1988. (See Dante Studies, CVII, 151.) Reviewed by:
Janet Levarie Smarr, in Comparative Literature Studies, XXVII, No. 3, 249-252.
Noakes, Susan. Timely Reading: Between Exegesis and Interpretation. Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press, 1988. (See Dante Studies, CVII, 151-152.) Reviewed by:
A. J. Minnis, in Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 142-144.
Oppenheimer, Paul. The Birth of the Modern Mind: Self, Consciousness, and the Invention of the Sonnet. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1989. (See Dante Studies, CVIII, 142-143.) Reviewed by:
Richard Moore, in American Book Review, XII, No. 5 (November-December),
30.
Payne, Roberta L. The Influence of Dante on Medieval English Dream Visions. New York-Bern-Frankfurt am Main-Paris: Peter Lang, 1989. (See Dante Studies, CVIII, 143-144.) Reviewed by:
R. A. Shoaf, in Studies in the Age of Chaucer, XII, 320-322.
Porcelli, Bruno. Dante maggiore e Boccaccio minore: strutture e modelli. Pisa: Giardini, 1987. Reviewed by:
Christopher Nissen, in Italica, LXVII, No. 1 (Spring),
76-77.
Rowe, Donald W. Through Nature to Eternity: Chaucer's "Legend of Good Women." Lincoln and London: University of Nebraska Press, 1988. (See Dante Studies, CVII, 155.) Reviewed by: Lisa J. Kiser, in Modern Philology, LXXXVII, No. 3 (February), 291-293;
[unsigned], in Medium Aevum, LIX, No. 1, 182.
Russell, Jeffrey Burton. The Prince of Darkness: Radical Evil and the Power of Good. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1988. Reviewed by:
Leonard R. N. Ashley, in Christianity and Literature, XXXIX,
No. 2 (Winter), 201-202.
Salm, Peter. Pinpoint of Eternity: European Literature in Search of the All-Encompassing Moment. Lanham, Maryland-New York-London: University Press of America, 1986. (See Dante Studies, CVII, 175.) Reviewed by:
Raymond Adolph Prier, in Philosophy and Literature, XIV,
No. 2 (October), 415-416
Saly, John. Dante's Paradiso: The Flowering of the Self. New York: Pace University Press, 1989. (See Dante Studies, CVIII, 146-147.) Reviewed by:
Marianne Shapiro, in Lectura Dantis, VI (Spring), 150-153.
Schnapp, Jeffrey T. The Transfiguration of History at the Center of Dante's "Paradise." Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1986. (See Dante Studies, CV, 158.) Reviewed by:
Steven Botterill, in Comparative Literature, XLII, No. 4 (Fall), 365-367;
Donna Mancusi-Ungaro, in Italian Culture, VIII, 190-194.
Schumacher, Thomas L. The Danteum: A Study in the Architecture of Literature. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton Architectural Press, 1985. (See Dante Studies, CVI, 156.) Reviewed by:
H. Wayne Storey, in Italica, LXVII, No. 2 (Summer), 256-258.
Smarr, Janet Levarie. Boccaccio and Fiammetta: The Narrator as Lover. Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 1986. (See Dante Studies, CV, 159.) Reviewed by:
Albert Russell Ascoli, in Romance Quarterly, XXXVII, No. 2 (May), 251-254;
Tommaso Giartosio, in Rassegna della letteratura italiana,
XCIV, ser. VIII, No. 3 (settembre-dicembre), 208-209.
Sodi Risa B. A Dante of Our Time: Primo Levi and Auschwitz. New York: Peter Lang). (See above, under Studies.) Reviewed by:
Antonio Franceschetti, in Quaderni d'italianistica, XI,
No. 2 (Autunno), 335.
Spitzer, Leo. Representative Essays. Edited by Alban K. Forcione, Herbert Lindenberger, and Madeline Sutherland. With a Foreword by John Freccero. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press, 1988. (See below, under Addenda, Studies.) Reviewed by:
Donald W. Bleznick, in Hispania, LXXIII, No. 1 (March),
94-95.
Tambling, Jeremy. Dante and Difference: Writing in the 'Commedia'. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988. Reviewed by:
Ronald B. Herzman, in Studies in the Age of Chaucer, XII, 327-331;
Alan Nagel, in Philological Quarterly, LXIX, No. 4 (Fall),
516-518.
Taylor, Karla. Chaucer Reads "The Divine Comedy." Stanford, California: Stanford University Press, 1989. (See Dante Studies, CVIII, 151-152.) Reviewed by:
Nicholas R. Havely, in Studies in the Age of Chaucer, XII, 331-333;
Howard H. Schless, in Envoi, II, No. 1 (Spring), 206-207.
Vance, Eugene. Mervelous Signals: Poetics and Sign Theory in the Middle Ages. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1986. (See Dante Studies, CV, 161.) Reviewed by:
Mark Parker, in Lectura Dantis, VII (Fall), 151-152.
Vallone, Aldo. Strutture e modulazioni nella Divina Commedia. Firenze: Olschki. Reviewed by:
Amilcare A. Iannucci, in Quaderni d'italianistica, XI,
No. 2 (Autunno), 332.
Barolini, Teodolinda. "Ricreare la creazione divina: l'arte aracnea nella cornice dei superbi." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 145-164.
Italian version of the article "Re-presenting What God Presented: The Arachnean Art of Dante's Terrace of Pride" (see Dante Studies, CVI, 125-126).
Cassell, Anthony K. "Il sapore dell'amore: i canti dell'invidia." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 165-183.
Italian version of the article "The Letter of Envy: Purgatorio
XIII-XIV" (see Dante Studies, CIII, 144).
Davis, Charles T. "Roma e Babilonia in Dante." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 267-295.
Italian version of the article "Rome and Babylon in Dante"
(see Dante Studies, CI, 198).
Della Terza, Dante. "Introduzione. La critica dantesca in America: La lezione singletoniana." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 7-22.
Reprint of the essay which appeared in Letture Classensi
(see Dante Studies, CVIII, 127).
Ferrante, Joan. "Parole e immagini nel Paradiso: Riflessi del Divino." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 203-219.
Italian version of the article "Words and Images in the Paradiso:
Reflections of the Divine" (see Dante Studies, CII,
153).
Frankel, Margherita. "La similitudine della zara (Purgatorio VI, 1-12) e il rapporto fra Dante e Virgilio nell'antipurgatorio." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 113-143.
Analyzes the opening simile of Purgatorio VI--the "gioco
de la zara"--and discusses the possible reasons that Dante
may have had in identifying the loser with Virgil. To determine
the possible reasons for this apparently harsh judgment on Dante's
part ("questo malanimo dantesco"), Frankel reviews the
first eight cantos of Purgatorio with regard to the relationship
of the Pilgrim with his guide.
Gerry, Thomas M. F. "Dante, C. D. Burns and Sinclair Ross: Philosophical Issues in As For Me and My House." In Mosaic, XXII, No. 1 (Winter, 1989), 113-122.
Employing the Divine Comedy as a frame of reference, Sinclair
Ross aligns each of his characters with some section of Dante's
masterwork. Philip, for example, has a "Purgatorial"
orientation, while Mrs. Bentley is simply "Infernal."
Ultimately Ross's appropriation of Dante's imagery enables readers
to see beyond the immediate limitations of the text itself, suggesting
a Dantean awakening as subtext.
Hollander, Robert, and Albert Rossi. "Il repubblicanesimo di Dante." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 297-323.
Italian version of the article "Dante's Republican Treasury"
(see Dante Studies, CV, 151).
Iannucci, Amilcare A. "Musica e ordine nella Divina Commedia (Purgatorio II)." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 87-111.
Italian version of the article "Casella's Song and Tuning of the Soul" (see above, under Studies).
Jacoff, Rachel. "Le lacrime di Beatrice: Inferno II." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 23-36.
Italian version of the article "The Tears of Beatrice: Inferno
II" (see Dante Studies, CI, 204-205).
Kay, Richard. "Il giorno della nascita di Dante e la dipartita di Beatrice." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 243-265.
Proposes an allegorical reading of the Vita Nuova, according
to which the day of Beatrice's death--June 8, 1290--, coinciding
with the period (under the sign of the Gemini), might even be
the exact day on which Dante reached his 25th year, i.e., the
age of responsibility and wisdom. "Il mio argomento, in breve,
sarà che Dante amava Beatrice come causa della sua massima
felicità e che la rappresentò viva sulla terra per
gli anni della vita sua, sinché ritenne che la felicità
potesse trovarsi in questa vita; ma quando il suo potere razionale
giunse a perfezione nel venticinquesimo anno egli fu allora in
grado di discernere che la sua massima beatitudine poteva raggiungersi
solo nella vita eterna, e il differimento di questa felicità
fu rappresentato allegoricamente con la dipartita di Beatrice."
Mazzotta, Giuseppe. "La luce di Venere e la poesia di Dante." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 325-352.
Italian version of the article "The Light of Venus and the
Poetry of Dante" (see Dante Studies, CV, 154).
Picone, Michelangelo. "Baratteria e stile e comico in Dante (Inferno XXI-XXII)." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 63-86.
Reprint of the essay which appeared in Letture Classensi
as "Giulleria e poesia nella Commedia: una lettura
intertestuale di Inferno XXI-XXII" (see Dante Studies,
CVIII, 144).
Pietropaolo, Domenico. "Dante's Concept of Nobility and the Eighteenth-Century Tuscan Aristocracy: An Unknown Study of the Convivio." In Man and Nature / L'Homme et la Nature, V (1986), 141-152.
Poggesi considers Dante's definition of nobility much more "modern"
than Aristotle's (contrary to most noblemen of his time) because
it does not take into account wealth and genealogy but focuses
on individual merit. Poggesi stresses that Dante is not only a
subject for academic discussions, but especially an authoritative
magister vitae, in perfect agreement with those Enlightenment
ideas that Poggesi was trying to spread in Tuscany.
Pietropaolo, Domenico. "Giovanni Gaetano Bottari (1689-1775) and the Issue of Dante's Originality: A Case of Enlightened Erudition." In The Enlightenment in a Western Mediterranean Context, edited by F. Gerson, A. Percival, D. Pietropaolo (Toronto: Society for Mediterranean Studies, 1984), pp. 117-126.
Although Bottari's critical method is still deeply indebted to
traditional approaches, he shows, in the examined work, a deep
interest in applying the method of science in solving literary
problems. Using the concepts of "chance occurrence,"
"conjecture," and "probability" typical of
the empirical skepticism of the new science, instead of the traditional
deductivity, Bottari formulates the hypothesis that Guerrin
meschino plagiarizes the Divine Comedy and not viceversa,
as many of his contemporaries affirmed. Bottari's use of this
new approach shows that even in fields less open to innovation
(he was the librarian of a Cardinal in Rome) the spirit of the
new culture starts to develop.
Poss, Richard L. "The Veil in Rime 52: Petrarch's Secular Butterfly." In Italian Culture, VII (1986-1989), 7-16.
Discusses Petrarch's varied use of the word "velo" in
the Canzoniere and makes pointed comparisons to Dante's
similarly varied use of the same term in the Comedy.
Psaki, Regina. "La critica dantesca ortodossa e gli allegoristi." In L'idea deforme: Interpretazioni esoteriche di Dante, edited by Maria Pia Pozzato, Introduzione di Umberto Eco. Postfazione di Alberto Asor Rosa (Milano: Bompiani, 1989), pp. 263-279.
Psaki briefly reviews "i criteri e le aspettative della critica
positivista emersa nell'Ottocento, e le basi del suo disprezzo
per il lavoro di Rossetti e di Pascoli." She then passes
to a consideration of the "critica estetico-idealista"
(Croce et al.) and the quarrel with the theses of Luigi Valli,
and concludes with a section on "gli allegoristi e gli studi
danteschi contemporanei."
Rossi, Albert L. (Joint author). "Il repubblicanesimo
di Dante." See Hollander, Robert....
Schnapp, Jeffrey T. "Virgilio madre e Beatrice ammiraglio: Generi grammaticali e letterari nella Commedia." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 221-242.
Italian version of the article "Dante's Sexual Solecisms:
Gender and Genre in the Commedia" (see Dante Studies,
CVII, 156).
Shoaf, R. A. "'Lo gel che m'era intorno al cor' (Pg. XXX, 97) e 'Frigidus circum praecordia sanguis' (Geo. II, 484): la trascendenza dantesca di Virgilio." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 185-201.
Italian version of the article "'Lo gel che m'era intorno
al cor' (Purg. 30.97) and 'Frigidus circum praecordia sanguis'
(Geo. 2.484): Dante's Transcendence of Virgil" (see
Dante Studies, CVIII, 149).
Spitzer, Leo. Representative Essays. Edited by Alban K. Forcione, Herbert Lindenberger, and Madeline Sutherland. With a Foreword by John Freccero. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press, 1988. xx, 484 p.
Contains three classic essays on Dante: "Speech and Language
in Inferno XIII" (1942); "The Farcical Elements
in Inferno XXI-XXIII" (1944); and "The Addresses
to the Reader in the Commedia" (1955).
Stephany, William A. "L'autoadempimento delle profezie di Pier della Vigna: l'Elogio di Federico II e Inferno XIII." In Studi americani su Dante...(q.v.), pp. 37-62.
Italian version of the article "Pier della Vigna's Self-Fulfilling
Prophecies: The 'Eulogy' of Frederick II and Inferno 13,"
in Traditio, XXXVIII (1982), 193-212.
Studi americani su Dante. Edited by Gian Carlo Alessio and Robert Hollander. Introduzione di Dante Della Terza. Milano: Franco Angeli, 1989. 358 p.
Contains essays on Dante by the following scholars: Teodolinda
Barolini, Anthony K. Cassell, Charles T. Davis, Dante Della Terza,
Joan M. Ferrante, Margherita Frankel, Robert Hollander, Amilcare
A. Iannucci, Rachel Jacoff, Richard Kay, Giuseppe Mazzotta, Michelangelo
Picone, Albert Rossi, Jeffrey T. Schnapp, R. A. Shoaf, and William
A. Stephany. Each essay is listed separately in the Addenda
of this bibliography under the individual author's name.
Edwards, Robert R. The Dream of Chaucer: Representation and Reflection in the Early Narratives. Durham, North Carolina, and London: Duke University Press, 1989. (See Dante Studies, CVIII, 128.) Reviewed by:
Stephen A. Barney, in Modern Language Quarterly, L, No.
2 (June, 1989), 183-186.